Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch

Name: Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch
Price: 36.96 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 8.1 (87 reviews)

Curated from 87 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 29, 2025

Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch

Brand: Jack & Pup

Price: $36

Snoop Score:

8.1

Sentiment

6.4

Popularity

8.2

Technical

8.7

Buy on Amazon for $36 See All Bully Sticks Reviews

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks are premium, all-natural dog chews designed specifically for large and medium dogs who are aggressive chewers. At 12 inches long and made from 100% beef bladder, these bully sticks provide a satisfying chew that helps relieve boredom and supports dental health. Consumer feedback highlights several positive aspects of these bully sticks. Many users report that they are effective in keeping dogs occupied for extended periods, with one owner saying, "Bully sticks literally gave me my sanity back with our puppy since they occupy him for so long." Additionally, pet owners appreciate that these chews are low odor and digestible, with comments such as, "Jack and Pup, got them online and were long lasting and not stinky." Overall, the Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks come highly recommended for their category, especially for dog owners looking for a long-lasting and engaging treat for their pets. With a notable combination of nutritional benefits and positive user experiences, these bully sticks are a solid choice for dog lovers.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Bully Sticks

It actually was super helpful with teething and helped her wiggle out the teeth she needed to lose.
Positive Feedback

They’re good in small amounts but from my experience can easily upset their stomach.
Negative Feedback

8.1

Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch

Buy on Amazon for $36

Teething Relief

10 / 10

Boredom & Anxiety Reduction

7 / 10

Dental Health Maintenance

9 / 10

Power Chewing for Larger Breeds

10 / 10

See how this compares to all Bully Sticks

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.

Helps with teething

“It actually was super helpful with teething and helped her wiggle out the teeth she needed to lose.”➕

“I torpedoed a dude's entire career because he was a bully **I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Tahnkoman** ”➕

Long-lasting chew

“My pup loves them too.”➕

“Costco bully sticks for my dog (left, $26) vs Amazon bully sticks (right, $30) 🫣”➕

“the $41 ones are the real deal, and my pup MUCH prefers them.”➕

“they are a life changer. He will chew on it for 30-45 minutes.”➕

Nutritious and engaging treat

“Are bully sticks safe for puppies? Hi everyone! First time poster here. We are bringing home our 8 w”➕

“I’ve read how they’re such awesome treats to keep dogs occupied, as well as nutritious.”➕

Helps keep dogs occupied

“Think it really saved me and my furniture during teething stage.”➕

Softens as chewed, good for teeth

“Bully sticks aren't too hard on their teeth and they soften up as they bite more into it.”➕

Digestible and less likely to cause blockages

“although bully sticks are very digestible and rarely cause intestinal blockage for dogs, they are still pretty dangerous for puppies.”➕

Safe chew with supervision

“This has given me a view that these treats are just too unsafe.”➕

“You can buy bully stick holders for exactly this reason.”➕

Digestible and low risk for dogs

“All my years of working with dogs and I only had one bad gut after a bully stick.”➕

Effective for dental health

“It's interesting that I've never run into a problem, as I've given bully sticks about monthly to my last 3 dogs.”➕

Fully digestible bully sticks

“A proper bully stick (beef pizzle) is fully digestible.”➕

Long-lasting and satisfying chew

“Jack and Pup, got them online and were long lasting and not stinky.”➕

Low odor bully sticks

“There is a brand that makes an not smelly!”➕

Dogs enjoy the bully sticks

“Oh my god I can't stand the smell.”➕

“Not even the “odor-free” ones.”➕

“Best brand of Bully sticks I just want to get the best for my aussie pup. She’s 4 months old. We’ve ”➕

“My puppy loves the Jack and Pup bully sticks.”➕

Keeps dogs occupied for extended periods

“it is the only chew that she will keep herself occupied with for more than 2 minutes.”➕

Helps with dog boredom

“Bully sticks literally gave me my sanity back with our puppy since they occupy him for so long.”➕

Effective for teething puppies

“Bully sticks are amazing! My pup stopped chewing on everything, she was calm and didn’t have a care in the world.”➕

Engaging for dogs

“My pup loves this bully stick i got him and yesterday spent a whole hour on it.”➕

“I miss the days when my girl could take hours, or even just 1, chewing up a treat.”➕

“She spends maybe an hour a day chewing on them at 8 months old now.”➕

Low calorie treat when monitored

“it's perfectly fine.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.

Can upset stomachs

“They’re good in small amounts but from my experience can easily upset their stomach.”➕

“YMMV, but mine threw up violently after chewing on one for 10 or so minutes.”➕

Potential choking hazard for puppies

“Bully buddy. Absolute game changer.”➕

Veterinary concerns regarding puppy safety

“our vet says bully sticks are still dangerous for puppies...”➕

Strong smell of some bully sticks

“The smell!!! Oh god the smell!!!!”➕

“the smell was so bad I had to throw it away it just made me so nauseous.”➕

“The Jack and Pup brand sucks and they smell like cow shit.”➕

Strong smell of bully sticks

“Yes, they’re awful, and unfortunately, I haven’t come across any that don’t smell like a dead animal’s hind end.”➕

Awareness of the origin of bully sticks can be off-putting

“I remember the day I found out bully sticks are actually bull penises. I still wish I didn’t know.”➕

Potential choking hazard

“If you puppy gets the end out of the Kong and she swallows it whole that is a very expensive surgery.”➕

Varied quality between brands

“Plus the quality of the bully seems to vary greatly.”➕

“20 minutes for a bully stick is crazy fast.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product Name	Price	Score	See Details	Buy Now
Redbarn Pet Products All Natural Braided Bully Sticks	$49	8.5	Details	Buy
Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch	$36	8.1	Details	Buy
Redbarn Pet Products All Natural Bully Sticks	$24	7.8	Details	Buy
Natural Farm Odor-Free Select Bully Sticks	$49	7.5	Details	Buy
Mighty Paw Naturals 12" Bully Sticks for Dogs	$29	7.4	Details	Buy
Jack & Pup 6 Inch Bully Sticks for Medium Dogs	$19	7.0	Details	Buy
Best Bully Sticks 6 Inch Thick Bully Sticks for Dogs	$21	6.9	Details	Buy
I and Love and You No Stink Free Ranger Bully Stix	$15	6.6	Details	Buy
Best Pet Supplies GigaBite Bully Sticks - 20 Pack	$16	6.4	Details	Buy
Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks for Small Dogs	$11	6.1	Details	Buy
Woofley's 4-5" Bulk Bully Sticks - 50 Count	$47	5.9	Details	Buy
Bow Wow Labs 6" Bully Sticks for Dogs	$27	5.8	Details	Buy
Nature Gnaws Braided Bully Sticks for Dogs	$14	4.8	Details	Buy
Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Raw Dog Treats, Bully Sticks	$19	4.5	Details	Buy
PawLove Bully Dog Chew, 3 OZ	$20	4.4	Details	Buy
Cadet Bully Sticks for Small Dogs	$54	4.3	Details	Buy
Canine Naturals Beef & Bully Sticks	$9	3.9	Details	Buy
ValueBull Bully Sticks for Small Dogs - 100 Count Bulk Pack	$96	3.8	Details	Buy
Natural Farm Bully Sticks - 6 Inch, 30 Pack	$21	3.7	Details	Buy
Best Bully Sticks 4 Inch Bully Sticks - Pack of 1	$22	3.2	Details	Buy
Bully Bunches Premium 6 Inch Bully Sticks for Dogs	$14	2.4	Details	Buy

Attribute	Redbarn Pet Products All Natural Braided Bully Sticks	Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch	Redbarn Pet Products All Natural Bully Sticks
Snoop Score	8.5	8.1	7.8
Sentiment	7.3	6.4	7.5
Popularity	8.7	8.2	6.2
Price	$49	$36	$24
Ingredient Quality
Scent & Odor
Size & Thickness Options
Dental Health Benefits
Rawhide Alternative
Brand Reputation & Sourcing

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.

Suggestions for alternative chews

“My super chewer loves yak cheese. They last him about a week.”➕

“My guy can go for days and days with one if it is big enough!!”➕

“Out of all the chews I’ve tried, it lasts the longest for my dog.”➕

“We used to call them 'babysitters' they would hold attention for so long.”➕

Alternative chew suggestions

“Doesn't break into pieces - just sort of dissolves over time with chewing.”➕

Discussion about alternative chews like yak milk

“Have you tried yak milk chews?”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’

Consult with vet regarding usage

“Bully sticks are one of the only things that have gotten me through the last 4 months.”➕

Comparison with Costco products

“I can’t buy these for my dogs without making the obligatory bag of dicks joke”➕

“Costco bags were over 1lb vs the 8oz bags from Amazon 😭 I’ve been wasting money for months”➕

Recommendations for alternative chews

“Their chews are high quality and no odor.”➕

“with super close supervision our girl sometimes gets knee bones.”➕

Preference for alternative bully stick brands

“They last forever and when I notice she has unbraided them, I take the 3 pieces away.”➕

“buying in bulk helps with the cost.”➕

“My pup does bite chunks off occasionally of these though, so I'm going to pick up a pack of the braided ones next time.”➕

Advice on chew holders for safety

“Seconded, I've tried different brands and Jack & Pup are the best.”➕

Discussion about alternatives to bully sticks for teething puppies

“Problem is, that's like $10 a day on cow penises.”➕

“Costco's bully sticks are huge and pretty reasonably priced.”➕

“Tell me you're a dog owner without telling me you're a dog owner: "I spend $10 dollars a day in cow penises".”➕

“It's a nice non splintering wood.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.

Advice on using holders for safety

“Thanks you! I will definitely get him one of the holders when we do introduce him to bully sticks.”➕

“It really holds it in there and makes it easier for him to hold it.”➕

Concerns about choking hazards

“I’ve seen mixed reviews on bully sticks and would prefer not to give him those.”➕

Variability in individual dog reactions to chews

“my god they're expensive and she chews through it so fast.”➕

Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch

Curated from 87 real Reddit conversations

Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch

Snoop's Take

Jack&Pup Thick Bully Sticks 12 Inch

Teething Relief

Boredom & Anxiety Reduction

Dental Health Maintenance

Power Chewing for Larger Breeds

What it does well!

Where it needs some work!

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Hidden Hero Hacks

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

Cautionary Callouts

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories