MAYBELLINE Super Stay 24 Liquid Lipstick Makeup

Curated from 98 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 25, 2025

MAYBELLINE Super Stay 24 Liquid Lipstick Makeup

Brand: MAYBELLINE

Price: $8

Snoop Score:

5.8

Sentiment

5.5

Popularity

5.7

Technical

5.1

Buy on Amazon for $8 See All Lipstick Reviews

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

Maybelline Super Stay 24 is a 2-step liquid lipstick that provides long lasting, highly pigmented color with a moisturizing twist. It applies in two easy steps, using a precision tip for the liquid formula followed by a conditioning balm to lock in hydration. Consumer sentiment is a mixed bag with a strong lean towards durability and vibrant color. Users rave that "they're well pigmented, comfortable to wear" and appreciate its long-lasting hold, yet some complain about a sticky, patchy finish and discrepancies in advertised shades. The debate among users highlights both its robust staying power and some formulation inconsistencies that leave a few scratching their heads. In conclusion, despite some polarizing feedback regarding texture and shade fidelity, this product is recommended for those seeking long wear and intense coloration within its category.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Lipstick

They're well pigmented, comfortable to wear (non drying), stay on well and at a good price.
Positive Feedback

Nothing worked in making it less sticky or transferring, so eventually I threw it away.
Negative Feedback

5.8

MAYBELLINE Super Stay 24 Liquid Lipstick Makeup

Buy on Amazon for $8

Daily Wear

3 / 10

Special Occasions

9 / 10

Professional Makeup

6 / 10

Sensitive or Dry Lips

2 / 10

See how this compares to all Lipstick

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.

Well pigmented and comfortable to wear

“They're well pigmented, comfortable to wear (non drying), stay on well and at a good price.”➕

Long-lasting without drying

“Maybelline vinyl ink liquid lipsticks lost pigment I bought these lipsticks about a year ago, and th”➕

“I also bought mine one years ago more or less, but they're still like new. I remember some post from”➕

“I had this problem and I literally shook the crap out of it for over 2 minutes and the color improve”➕

“This is one of the only few formulas that stay on my lips for a long time and I love the smell.”➕

Well pigmented colors

“it stays sticky on me for the entire time it's on my lips, until I take it off.”➕

“it’s like GLUE.”➕

Long-lasting without flaking

“It has never ever flaked off for me like you are describing, that’s so nuts compared to my experience.”➕

“But on the plus side, this makes the product less drying and have a more elegant wear (no more flaking off, just a gradual fade).”➕

Blends well before setting

“I love how well these blend together before they set.”➕

Good day-to-day color options

“I prefer this over Lover a million times. Does not make me look sick and great day to day color.”➕

Comfortable wear

“it doesn't get too sticky or tacky on my lips and lasts for a long time.”➕

Comfortable to wear

“These are definitely the most comfortable lipsticks I have (I'm so done with drying liquid lipsticks).”➕

“I don’t care that I have to keep reapplying, it feels and looks so good ❤️.”➕

Comfortable and long-wearing

“I really love it, find it comfortable and very long-wearing.”➕

“Whoa! That sucker stayed put!”➕

Good application technique improves results

“You just wait one minute for them to dry.”➕

Some shades work well for long-lasting wear

“You’re definitely right on the formulas varying by shade.”➕

“The shade pioneer is my HG whereas the shade Heroine is quite patchy on me.”➕

Long-lasting wear even overnight

“I love this product cause its literally the only lip stuff i have found that doesn't wear off.”➕

Almost transfer proof

“Omg, I'm obsessed with this lipstick, I have several and it truly is almost transfer proof.”➕

Pleasant vanilla cupcake scent

“smells like vanilla cupcake.”➕

Flattering terracotta mid-tone nude

“Maybelline’s newish Mauve for Me may be their most flattering terracotta mid tone nude yet.”➕

“Omg you life saver!! I’ve been dying for a lip color like the Maybelline one but all of the nude lipsticks I get pull off more like pink-purple.”➕

Beautiful long-lasting color

“the color is beautiful stayed put after two showers and isn’t sticky.”➕

“they’re the only thing I’ve found that can hold up through a 12-hour shift.”➕

Effective application technique improves performance

“Works for me for the rest of the day.”➕

“After it dries I press my lips together and that helps.”➕

Good value for the price

“To call this product longwearing isn’t enough. It’s more like semi-permanent.”➕

Effective removal with SuperStay remover

“It gets rid of my SuperStay 24 hour lip color fairly easily.”➕

Long-lasting wear

“Applied it around 9pm and accidentally slept in it.”➕

Improved results with blotting technique

“It got rid of all the stickiness for me if I blot immediately after application.”➕

Trustworthy staying power

“I love this stuff! It is the only lipstick I trust to go on and stay on.”➕

“I've just bought lover as my paler everyday.”➕

Helpful swatch videos available

“BeautywithEmilyFox has some great swatch videos for these on YouTube that I’ve found super helpful in choosing new shades.”➕

Variety of shades for everyday use

“Ringleader is definitely pink - like the horrible 80s mauve that's everywhere now.”➕

“I love 015 (lover i think it is?) Kind of a purple pink. Phenomenal.”➕

Wears well throughout the day

“I sort of love this thing haha”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.

Formula can be sticky or tacky

“Nothing worked in making it less sticky or transferring, so eventually I threw it away.”➕

Patchy and sticky formula

“All in all feels like I ate a chewing gum and stuck it on my lips.”➕

“my lips always ended up looking patchy, goopy, sticky.”➕

Sticky and drying formula

“it feels a bit sticky and drying. I’ve extremely dry lips.”➕

“This is so disappointing.”➕

Color discrepancy from advertisement

“The shade difference between what they advertise and what it is in reality is unbelievable.”➕

“Most lipsticks that shown as peachy browny nudes turn out to be pink.”➕

“The difference is maddening!”➕

“They literally just put the same arcrylic swatch without understanding that lipsticks are not opaque.”➕

Inconsistent formula across shades

“There is definitely inconsistency in some of the formulas from shade to shade.”➕

“I was surprised when I saw people recommending it as a long-standing liquid lipstick.”➕

Does not stay on during eating and drinking

“Eating, drinking, kissing... It just comes right off, smudges all around my mouth, I leave stains on everything and everyone.”➕

Lip balm on top causes removal

“Are you applying lip balm on top of the lipstick? That causes it to start coming off for me.”➕

Difficulty finding balm refills

“I don't understand why Maybelline keeps this product in their line but not the balm refills.”➕

Difficult removal process

“Mine was miserable. Peeled off in chunks but didn't even do that well.”➕

Inconsistent shade availability

“Weird... the shade "seductress" is not shown in that link, even when I click "show all shades."”➕

Limited color selection

“I just wish the maybelline and revlon super stay lip colours came in more interesting colours!”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product Name	Price	Score	See Details	Buy Now
MAYBELLINE Color Sensational Lipstick, Nude Lust	$5	8.8	Details	Buy
L'OREAL PARIS Colour Riche Original Creamy, Hydrating Satin Lipstick Tickled Pink	$7	8.6	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick Makeup, Seductress, Light Rosey Nude	$9	7.7	Details	Buy
wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick Dark Pink Frost	$1	7.3	Details	Buy
wet n wild Mega Last Matte Lip Color, Bare it All	$2	7.2	Details	Buy
The Lip Bar - Nonstop Liquid Matte Lipstick, Bawse Lady (Blue Red)	$13	7.0	Details	Buy
L.A. COLORS Pout Chaser Lipstick, Dandy CLIPC849	$0	6.6	Details	Buy
REVLON Super Lustrous Lipstick, 405 Silver City Pink	$6	6.4	Details	Buy
e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick - Black Cherry	$5	6.3	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Super Stay Teddy Lip Tint	$9	6.2	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Super Stay 24 Liquid Lipstick Makeup	$8	5.8	Details	Buy
wet n wild Mega Last High-Shine Lipstick Lip Color	$2	5.7	Details	Buy
Rimmel Lasting Finish Lipstick - 002 Candy	$4	5.6	Details	Buy
COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lipstick Cream, Sweetheart Blush 390	$4	5.4	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Maybelline Super Stay Vinyl Ink Longwear Lipcolor	$9	5.0	Details	Buy
REVLON Super Lustrous Lipstick, 245 Smoky Rose	$6	4.7	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Color Sensational Ultimatte Matte Lipstick More Berry	$6	4.7	Details	Buy
Rimmel Lasting Finish Lipstick, Candy	$4	4.5	Details	Buy
REVLON Super Lustrous Lipstick, 463 Sassy Mauve	$6	4.2	Details	Buy
REVLON Super Lustrous The Luscious Mattes Lipstick, Make It Pink	$5	3.9	Details	Buy

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.

Community tips for improving lipstick performance

“Shake like you’ve never shaken before !!”➕

Tips for application techniques

“I blot it out onto the back of my hand and apply from there with a foam applicator so I can get the thinnest and most minimal layer possible.”➕

Seeking alternatives for conditioning balm

“I found a comment on another site that claims the Soft Lips lip balms seem to be the same thing.”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’

Questioning necessity of duplicates

“Why buy each color 3x though?”➕

Suggestion to try one tube before buying more

“You don't even know if you like it. Hop out to the drugstore, buy one.”➕

Variability in lipstick swatches

“Either Maybelline keeps switching its formulation to trip us OR - Touch of Spice shade has become SENTIENT and playing tricks on us!”➕

Need for personal swatching

“They look exactly the same in bullet form and you can only tell the minuscule difference when you actually swatch them.”➕

Desire for thorough reviews

“I really enjoyed your breakdown and this was a very thorough review.”➕

Difficulty finding flattering nude lip colors

“I always attributed it to the makeup not being green toned. I'm frustrated that I don't have more options for a flattering lip color besides a warm red or mauve.”➕

Discussion about similar shades

“Let me know if you wanna see it in natural light.”➕

“Almond pink and touch of spice literally looks same.”➕

Challenges in finding the right MLBB shade

“I finally able to find the perfect MLBB shade on the vinyl ink which is shade 115 peppy but somehow this formula doesn’t stay as well as the 2 step liquid.”➕

“This is a gorgeous color!”➕

“maybelline colorsensational series is awesome and stays super long.”➕

“I’d like to know what color this is as well!”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.

TikTok influence on purchasing decisions

“Those Vinyl Ink lipsticks look beautiful on the lips, that's another reason why it's hard for me to cancel this order.”➕

“The only reason everyone is raving is because Maybelline is doing a marketing campaign.”➕

MAYBELLINE Super Stay 24 Liquid Lipstick Makeup

Curated from 98 real Reddit conversations

MAYBELLINE Super Stay 24 Liquid Lipstick Makeup

Snoop's Take

MAYBELLINE Super Stay 24 Liquid Lipstick Makeup

Daily Wear

Special Occasions

Professional Makeup

Sensitive or Dry Lips

What it does well!

Where it needs some work!

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Hidden Hero Hacks

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

Cautionary Callouts

You May Also Like

Explore more Lipstick