Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets

Name: Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets
Price: 10.97 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5.6 (145 reviews)

Curated from 145 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: February 23, 2025

Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets

Brand: Tylenol

Price: $10

Snoop Score:

5.6

Sentiment

6.9

Popularity

4.8

Technical

5.7

Buy on Amazon for $10 See All Medications Reviews

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets are a widely recognized pain reliever and fever reducer designed to alleviate minor aches and pains, including headaches, backaches, and toothaches. This product is particularly favored for its effectiveness in providing temporary relief and has an excellent safety profile when used as directed. Consumer feedback highlights Tylenol's strength in managing mild pain and its ability to reduce fever, with one user noting, "it's the only thing that gives him any sort of peace to sleep." However, some users express concerns about its effectiveness for severe pain, stating, "Tylenol does fuck-all for severe pain for me." Overall, the sentiment is mixed, with many praising its safety and efficacy for minor symptoms while noting limitations for more intense pain. Considering the feedback, Tylenol Extra Strength is recommended for those seeking relief from mild discomfort and fever, but users with severe pain may want to explore other options. It remains a trusted choice for many, particularly in its category of pain relief medications.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Medications

When I broke my arm in the past, I only used Tylenol so it seems pretty unlikely I’d need something more.
Positive Feedback

I never thought Tylenol ever helps with ANY kind of pain at any milligrams.
Negative Feedback

5.6

Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets

Buy on Amazon for $10

Pain & Fever Relief

9 / 10

Diarrhea Symptom Control

6 / 10

Multi-Age Applicability

7 / 10

On-the-Go Convenience

6 / 10

See how this compares to all Medications

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.

Tylenol effective for fever relief

“When I broke my arm in the past, I only used Tylenol so it seems pretty unlikely I’d need something more.”➕

Tylenol is equivalent to acetaminophen and paracetamol

“It's still the same active ingredients?”➕

“Tylenol is a brand name.”➕

Tylenol effective for mild aches and fever relief

“Tylenol does absolutely nothing for severe pain in my experience.”➕

“Tylenol only works on fever for me.”➕

Tylenol effective for mild aches

“So while they may have short term pain relief effects, are these drugs slowing the healing process?”➕

“I wouldn't have been taking it if I wasn't already in pain.”➕

Tylenol does not inhibit healing

“Tylenol does not inhibit inflammation, rather it suppresses molecules responsible for delivering pain sensations to the brain.”➕

Tylenol provides effective pain relief for minor aches

“Pain went away, but my high glucose alarm went off and I was almost at 300 within an hour!”➕

“If you are using it extensively, then there might be a problem.”➕

Effective for teething pain relief

“it's the only thing that gives him any sort of peace to sleep.”➕

“Judge me all you want, but it got the point across.”➕

“For me it was more tied to my fears of being a bad mom and just medicating my baby willy nilly.”➕

Tylenol is effective for chronic pain management

“My doctor has me on 3,000 mg a day with no concerns.”➕

“It's been years and I'm fine.”➕

“Have had lots of blood work done recently, unrelated, and my liver is just fine.”➕

Tylenol has a good safety profile when used as directed

“My liver is fine and my Doctors don't think it is a concern at the moment.”➕

“Acetaminophen and drinking are going to lead you to cancer.”➕

Daily usage of Tylenol does not cause liver issues for everyone

“That isn't to say that you personally may not have issues because everyone is unique, but that's what the label says.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.

Ineffective for severe pain

“I never thought Tylenol ever helps with ANY kind of pain at any milligrams.”➕

“yeah Tylenol does fuck-all for severe pain for me.”➕

“I prefer Tylenol to percocet or oxycodone because they make me nauseous but also do nothing for pain.”➕

Tylenol does not have anti-inflammatory properties

“I’ve always been told Ibuprofen is better for that.”➕

“Yeah, acetaminophen has no anti-inflammatory properties.”➕

Concerns about over-medication

“Why? What’s wrong with giving a medication that would help your child feel better?”➕

“But I'm not going to cite sources when I remove comments from people claiming giving your kid Tylenol means they're going to get autism.”➕

Tylenol overdose is a serious risk

“Overdosing on Tylenol is a slow, painful way to die.”➕

“It’s messed up because I know she did it to get at me in some way but the fact her father found her just broke my heart.”➕

“Thanks for the informative response!”➕

Tylenol can be liver toxic if misused

“Acetaminophen is liver toxic.”➕

Potential for liver failure with improper use

“please skip this step and get the help you need!”➕

“He didn't realize they were all one and the same and was ingesting far more than the recommended dosages.”➕

“Agree it's a terrible way to die.”➕

Risk of accidental overdose due to combination medications

“Please people, read the labels, and talk to a pharmacist or doctor if you're confused.”➕

“There are still a gigantic amount though and it can't just be assumed that normal people read or understand the drug facts.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product Name	Price	Score	See Details	Buy Now
Imodium A-D Diarrhea Relief Caplets	$11	6.9	Details	Buy
Tylenol Extra Strength Acetaminophen Rapid Release Gels	$12	6.8	Details	Buy
Imodium A-D Anti-Diarrheal Medicine Softgels	$14	6.2	Details	Buy
Tylenol Liquid Pain Relief for Children & Adults	$12	5.7	Details	Buy
Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets	$10	5.6	Details	Buy
Tylenol 8 Hour Arthritis Pain Relief Tablets	$12	5.0	Details	Buy
Tylenol 8HR Arthritis Pain Relief Caplets	$12	3.5	Details	Buy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.

Tylenol arthritis has higher dosages compared to regular Tylenol

“Tylenol arthritis is just a higher dose of Tylenol at 650 mg vs 500 in extra strength and 350 in regular.”➕

Tylenol arthritis may have a different formulation including layers for extended release

“One layer dissolves more quickly than the other, so it should stay in your system a little longer.”➕

Discussion on the composition of Tylenol arthritis

“You can probably replicate the formula a lot cheaper than buying their product and adjust it to exactly what works best.”➕

Tylenol 8hr Arthritis is designed for extended release with a specific coating

“From the #1 Doctor Recommended brand for pain relief and fever reduction, TYLENOL® 8 HR Arthritis Pain Caplets provide fast-acting, temporary relief of minor arthritis, osteoarthritis and joint pain.”➕

Acetaminophen is commonly available in Japan

“Acetaminophen is a very normal medicine available in Japan, too, so there aren't other restrictions on it.”➕

“It’s also easy to find painkiller in Japan, might be different brand and sometimes different dosage, but not the end of the world even if you don’t bring your own.”➕

Tylenol is equivalent to Paracetamol in Portugal

“If you want brand, you ask for Ben-U-Ron, or you can get the exact same thing for a fraction of the price and just ask for Paracetamol.”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.

Personal anecdotes about pain management experiences

“I can’t imagine. I’m glad she wasn’t in pain though.”➕

Personal experiences with medication adherence in hospital settings

“Next option is to pull the legal card and emphasize to the doctors that they are “medically neglecting an elderly patient” — that’ll change their tune REAL QUICK!”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’

Generics and brand names have similar effectiveness

“From googling it appears to be the generic version of Claritin.”➕

“from my experience are non existent. They all work the same to me.”➕

“the active ingredients remain the same.”➕

Discussion on cost-effectiveness of dollar store medications

“The price per pill makes sense - I paid $3 for 10 pills for this Claritin knockoff, I'm sure I could get a bulk pack cheaper at Costco.”➕

Pharmacies in Italy may have different hours than expected.

“Bottom line is ALL the pharmacies were closed and you cannot buy basic meds like Benadryl or Tylenol at a grocery store!”➕

“Definitely bring some of the medicine you know works for you from home.”➕

“I highly, highly doubt that anywhere in Italy with an open grocery store didn’t have an open pharmacy or parafarmacia selling antihistamines.”➕

“some pharmacie stay open all day and in turn there are always some open on sundays.”➕

Discussion on Tylenol being the only pain medication provided in hospitals

“This makes no sense, why take the person off the meds they’re on for something that does nothing?”➕

Uncertainty about OTC medication supply regulations

“I feel like I'm an idiot, but what exactly is a two month supply of OTC medication?”➕

“For example with Tylenol you're only supposed to take 3000mg max a day, so depending on the strength of the pills you can do the math to figure out what the max would be for a month or two I guess?”➕

Personal experiences with bringing medications abroad

“Very smooth process where they really only verified and recorded my passport and photo.”➕

Discussion on costs of OTC medications

“I’d rather not have to pay higher prices for OTC meds while on board that’s why I’m bringing the medicine cabinet with us.”➕

“I don’t want to pay $10 for a little 6 pack of Tylenol or motrin somewhere.”➕

Personal anecdotes about carrying medications while traveling

“I practically carry a pharmacy onboard.”➕

“I assume most people do this.”➕

Mention of various OTC medications packed for travel

“I literally put all my OTC medicine into little baggies to save space; Excedrin, Claritin, heartburn.”➕

Discussion on bringing medications from the US

“When I visit this autumn I’m going to bring back a pack just in case.”➕

Discussion on packing medications for hiking

“I'm an non-American hiker so its easier for me to have these ready with me then see a town doctor and deal with additional paper work.”➕

“don't pack your fears.”➕

“I get migraines on occasion and would hate to be stuck a few days from town with one.”➕

Generics may not work the same for everyone

“One reason a person gets brand is because the formulation of a generic medication isn’t working as expected compared to the brand.”➕

“The generic headache/migraine acetaminophen does not actually work that well even though the active ingredients are the same.”➕

“But if it's a migraine, then really only the Excedrin Migraine works.”➕

Discussion on cost-effectiveness of medications

“Tylenol at my store is over $10, generic is $2.”➕

“Hate saying it, but Amazon has a generic brand of it, and it works just as well.”➕

“If a drug does not have the same active ingredients in the same quantities, than that is not a generic of that drug.”➕

Discussion on individual tolerance to acetaminophen

“just the idea of having another health problem make me really desperate.”➕

“Also on a large dose of painkillers like you!”➕

Awareness of dosage recommendations

“Isn't this stuff literally printed on the bottle? "Doseage not to exceed" etc etc?”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.

Opioid prescription reduction affects pain management

“Since the opioid epidemic began, doctors have cut down severely on the amount of opioid medication they prescribe.”➕

Concerns about habit-forming medications

“The way they throw this stuff around like candy is crazy.”➕

Discussion on Tylenol's effectiveness for pain relief

“Exclaimed "wow! So people in pain take Tylenol and it's just gone???" Like no that's not how that works but glad it helped him.”➕

“my god...that would be incredible if it worked. That would be no more fighting for effective analgesics.”➕

“I can’t imagine being able to take tylenol and anything actually happening.”➕

“she said it helped her so much. It'd barely make a difference to me!!”➕

Discussion on the misconception of Tylenol's link to autism

“how true is Tylenol linked to Autism?”➕

“It's not. It was a theory a researcher threw out there, and people jumped on it like it was fact.”➕

“The link here is the same one with the 'vaccines cause autism' rhetoric, so while both vaccination r”➕

“so it's Tylenol causes Autism too?”➕

Personal preferences for pain management medications

“At the lower doses it actually has an anti-anxiety effect, and people prescribe it for mixed anxiety/depression.”➕

Confusion around medication names and formulations

“Only time I say acetaminophen is when I’m describing the potential of liver damage.”➕

Concerns about overdose and anxiety over medication intake

“now I’m super anxious and kind of scared.”➕

“Unless you have some very, very serious liver issues, it’s not a problem.”➕

“Idk why I panic so bad over dumb stuff like this.”➕

“I feel your pain.”➕

Discussion on naming differences for acetaminophen globally

“I strongly prefer using the generic medication name as that leaves less room for ambiguity, in my experience.”➕

“Yeah, like why do the US always seem to use brand names rather than the actual medication name.”➕

“the generic is far more common.”➕

Placebo effect can influence medication effectiveness

“Buy generic but keep it in an empty bottle of the brand name stuff.”➕

Concerns about overdosing on Tylenol

“I overdosed on Tylenol when I was 12 or so, my braces were very tight and taking 2 pills didn't help so I took 2 more, then 2 more, I think I had 10 total.”➕

“It creates a significant barrier to opportunistic overdoses.”➕

Personal experiences with migraine medications

“drinking coffee with generic acetaminophen helps lessen migraines.”➕

Variability in medication effectiveness among individuals

“The response to medication can be different between people, that's one of the reasons why there are often different medications for the same problem.”➕

“If you take Lamotrigine for epilepsy you shouldn't switch to generics, but if you take it for myotonia it's not an issue.”➕

Divergent opinions on using pain medication for children

“Please don't use random internet strangers to make medical decisions.”➕

Discussion on Tylenol and alcohol interaction

“Lucky for her that alcohol saved her life.”➕

“Drinking a lot of booze can occupy the cytochrome proteins that metabolize such that they are not available for a time to process Tylenol.”➕

Anecdote on personal experiences with Tylenol overdose

“Painless and easy- if it's done right.”➕

Personal anecdotes regarding long-term use of acetaminophen

“Discuss it with your doctor if you'd like some more reassurance but you're totally within fine ranges.”➕

“Lol, almost three years later? Still good over here!”➕

Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets

Curated from 145 real Reddit conversations

Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets

Snoop's Take

Tylenol Extra Strength 500 mg Acetaminophen Caplets

Pain & Fever Relief

Diarrhea Symptom Control

Multi-Age Applicability

On-the-Go Convenience

What it does well!

Where it needs some work!

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Core Power Plays

Hidden Hero Hacks

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

Cautionary Callouts

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories