Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker

Curated from 86 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: April 2, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6
Product Image 7
Product Image 8
Product Image 9
Product Image 10
Product Image 11
Product Image 12
Product Image 13
Product Image 14
Product Image 15
Product Image 16
Product Image 17

Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker

Brand: Frigidaire
Price: $88
Snoop Score:
5.9
Sentiment
6.7
Popularity
5.7
Technical
5.6
Buy on Amazon for $88See All Ice Makers Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker is designed to produce clear ice cubes quickly and efficiently, making it an ideal addition to any kitchen or party setup. Users appreciate its ability to generate up to 26 lbs of ice per day, with many noting, "We love it! I’d much prefer it if my regular ice maker worked, but since it doesn’t, this is the next best thing." While many praise its user-friendly features and easy maintenance, some feedback indicates challenges with ice melting and durability issues, with a user stating, "the ice is good but when the ice melts the water can drip down the front if you don’t use it quickly enough." Overall, despite some concerns, the product is recommended for those in need of a reliable ice maker, especially for gatherings.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Ice Makers

We have one and it’s awesome.

Positive Feedback

It makes ice, but since there's no cooler, that ice melts and returns to the water reservoir.

Negative Feedback
Product
5.9
Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker
Buy on Amazon for $88
Home and Kitchen
5 / 10
Camping and RV Trips
5 / 10
Parties and Entertaining
6 / 10
Office and Small Businesses
9 / 10
See how this compares to all Ice Makers

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Produces ice quickly
“We have one and it’s awesome.”➕
“We love it! I’d much prefer it if my regular ice maker worked, but since it doesn’t, this is the next best thing.”➕
Good performance with cold water
“Performance is dependent on where you are using it. I find it works better adding ice cold water from say a Brita pitcher vs. tap water.”➕
Useful for parties when fridge ice maker is insufficient
“We've had one for over 5 years and use it when we're having a party and the fridge ice maker won't keep up.”➕
Solid machine if counter space allows
“It's good, kind of bulky if you're in a smaller kitchen but if you have the counter space it's a solid machine.”➕
Produces a large amount of ice quickly
“Works well, and is always on. No complaints so far.”➕
“Great investment and no worry of flooding from a fridge ice maker.”➕
User-friendly and easy to clean
“Definitely! We use ours every day. I think we’ve had it for 3 years now”➕
User-friendly cleaning
“I clean it with bleach every couple of month. No issues at all.”➕
Effective self-cleaning mode
“I just fill it with 50/50 water and vinegar and let it run on that and rinse it out well afterwards”➕
Encouragement to clean ice makers
“Just checked mine. It was rough. Clean your ice makers!”➕
Vinegar solution recommended for cleaning
“I’d do a 50/50 with white vinegar, run it a cycle or two.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Cleaning required to maintain performance
“It makes ice, but since there's no cooler, that ice melts and returns to the water reservoir.”➕
“even if I transferred the ice to a proper freezer it was so wet it would all become a giant clump.”➕
Ice melts and can leak if not used quickly
“the ice is good but when the ice melts the water can drip down the front of you don’t use it quickly enough.”➕
Durability issues reported
“Having fresh ice on hand is a game changer.”➕
Generates no ice
“The ice make is a giant piece of junk, and has broken multiple times.”➕
Initial ice cubes are small and melt quickly
“If it makes the small white tube like ice cubes, stay away. Those things melt instantly.”➕
Does not keep ice cold without transferring it
“Does it keep ice or you have to transfer to a freezer?”➕
Durability issues with rust
“I loved it. Regularly cleaned it as it got constant use. But the metal prongs things are rusted.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
MAXEVE Ice Maker CountertopMAXEVE Ice Maker Countertop$69
8.6
DetailsBuy
Antarctic Star Nugget Ice Makers CountertopAntarctic Star Nugget Ice Makers Countertop$169
7.5
DetailsBuy
Sweetcrispy Countertop Ice MakerSweetcrispy Countertop Ice Maker$55
7.0
DetailsBuy
ZAFRO Countertop Ice MakerZAFRO Countertop Ice Maker$89
6.9
DetailsBuy
EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker MachineEUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker Machine$89
6.7
DetailsBuy
EUHOMY Commercial Ice Maker MachineEUHOMY Commercial Ice Maker Machine$329
6.6
DetailsBuy
Silonn Ice Maker CountertopSilonn Ice Maker Countertop$74
6.5
DetailsBuy
DUMOS Ice Maker Countertop Ice MachineDUMOS Ice Maker Countertop Ice Machine$69
6.5
DetailsBuy
Aeitto Nugget Ice Maker CountertopAeitto Nugget Ice Maker Countertop$599
6.1
DetailsBuy
Frigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top Ice MakerFrigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top Ice Maker$89
6.0
DetailsBuy
Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice MakerFrigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker$88
5.9
DetailsBuy
Crzoe Portable Countertop Ice Maker MachineCrzoe Portable Countertop Ice Maker Machine$39
5.9
DetailsBuy
Silonn Nugget Ice Maker CountertopSilonn Nugget Ice Maker Countertop$189
5.6
DetailsBuy
Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Ice MakerFrigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Ice Maker$84
5.5
DetailsBuy
YITAHOME 120LBS/24H Commercial Ice Maker MachineYITAHOME 120LBS/24H Commercial Ice Maker Machine$329
5.4
DetailsBuy
HealSmart Ice Maker for CountertopHealSmart Ice Maker for Countertop$54
5.3
DetailsBuy
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice MakerGE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker$449
5.2
DetailsBuy
Electactic Ice Makers Countertop Portable Ice Maker MachineElectactic Ice Makers Countertop Portable Ice Maker Machine$69
4.8
DetailsBuy
Silonn Ice Makers CountertopSilonn Ice Makers Countertop$154
4.7
DetailsBuy
SMUG Countertop Ice MakerSMUG Countertop Ice Maker$55
3.2
DetailsBuy
rosmena Bullet Ice Maker with Self-Cleaning Functionrosmena Bullet Ice Maker with Self-Cleaning Function$57
2.8
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Discussion about Costco's ice availability
“No way I'll ever get an ice maker when I can get the already made ice so cheap.”➕
“It wouldn't surprise me if some local laws forbid Costco to sell ice in certain locations.”➕
“We don’t have ice in my local stores in California.”➕
“In san antonio the bags of ice are in the attached liquor store.”➕
Surprise at ice maker options without keeping ice cold
“I was surprised to learn that pretty much none of these little machines even at double or triple the price will actually "keep" the ice.”➕
Discussion about performance based on water temperature
“Frigidaire Ice Maker Good morning, afternoon, and evening, depending on when you read this…”➕
General discussion about ice maker reliability and usage
“Frigidaire counter top ice maker! Worth it?”➕
Comparison with previous models
“Has anyone tried the new Frigidaire Ice Maker? Does "Automated Self Cleaning" actually work?”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Found at a low price in thrift store
“Found it brand new at the Goodwill for 8 bucks!”➕
Discussion on pricing and comparisons with other brands
“Saw this for $199 at Costco today. I wanted to look it up and see some reviews before purchasing.”➕
“Have it, love it. I like it a) because it’s cheaper than the Opal and b) because it’s smaller than the Opal.”➕
Video resources for troubleshooting
“It covers the top reasons why ice makers stop working and shows some fixes for various brands, including Frigidaire.”➕
“The drain for the coils in the back was completely blocked with ice. I melted all the ice, put it back together, and now I have ice.”➕
Consideration of ice maker placement and performance
“So now we have to open the freezer to get ice like it's some sort of 3rd world! The horror! But hey at least it works, so we can rough it.”➕
“Consider the water quality and in my experience that contributes to its longevity.”➕
“This. In the door is especially bad.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Discussion about the risks of fridge ice makers
“My parents' old fridge's water line broke while they were asleep and it cost them tens of thousands in damages.”➕
“The ones that put a maker in the refrigerator section are prone to failure.”➕
“the ice maker is slow, especially in warm weather. It does not meet the demand of our 4 person household during the warmest weather.”➕
“My ice maker in the fridge section is always acting up. Spent an entire weekend rebuilding it recently.”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Beverage Refrigerators
Top Beverage Refrigerators for Perfectly Chilled Drinks
Top Beverage Refrigerators for Perfectly Chilled Drinks
Explore Beverage Refrigerators
Kegerators
Top Kegerators for Home Draft Beer
Top Kegerators for Home Draft Beer
Explore Kegerators