Magic Mill Pro Food Dehydrator Machine

Curated from 63 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: February 14, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6
Product Image 7

Magic Mill Pro Food Dehydrator Machine

Brand: Magic Mill
Price: $139
Snoop Score:
5.9
Sentiment
5.6
Popularity
6.8
Technical
4.8
Buy on Amazon for $139See All Dehydrators Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The Magic Mill Pro Food Dehydrator Machine is a high-performance appliance designed to dry a variety of foods ranging from jerky and meat to herbs and fruit. It uses a rear-mounted fan for superior heat distribution and features a digital thermostat and timer for precise control, ensuring your dried super-snacks come out just right. Community chatter reveals a mixed bag of opinions. Many users are quick to praise its reliability, with one delighted customer exclaiming, "Works great, I love it." However, not everyone is singing its praises as some complaints highlight dubious temperature controls and an over-reliance on plastic components, which leaves a few skeptical about its longevity and consistency under load. Overall, the dehydrator stands out for its versatility and ease of use, making it a solid recommendation for anyone serious about homemade drying—even if you have to overlook a few quirks flagged by the community.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Dehydrators

Very quiet, Temps hold steady.

Positive Feedback

I was disappointed to see that most components were plastic, including the entire interior.

Negative Feedback
Product
5.9
Magic Mill Pro Food Dehydrator Machine
Buy on Amazon for $139
Jerky & Meat Drying
8 / 10
Fruit & Vegetable Preservation
7 / 10
Herb & Spice Dehydration
7 / 10
Pet Treats Preparation
8 / 10
See how this compares to all Dehydrators

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Reliable performance and durability (quiet operation and stable temperature control)
“Very quiet, Temps hold steady.”➕
“It's not very loud. I don't notice it in the next room over if I'm watching TV.”➕
“Been good to me so far.”➕
Wide temperature range for versatile applications
“the trays on this dehydrator have a raised hole in the center which fit my Numakers spool perfectly, almost as if it was meant to happen at one point.”➕
“I got so excited when I saw this post you’re awesome thank you again!”➕
Reliable performance and durability
“Works great, I love it.”➕
“Going strong after 3 years.”➕
“Great, I just bought one today. Should arrive by Monday.”➕
“Love it and it works excellent.”➕
Creative culinary applications
“Works great. Use mine for setting my sugar cookie frosting, fruit leather, edible glitter for my baked goods, and some banana chips so far.”➕
Efficient dehydration performance with reduced drying time
“Dam is it worth it. Love this thing. So much less hassle.”➕
“What a step up from that old Nesco I was using.”➕
Effective dehydration results despite unconventional temperature readings
“The finished product tells me everything I need to know, which is that it's doing what it says and I'm getting safe to consume jerky.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Excessive plastic components in construction
“I was disappointed to see that most components were plastic, including the entire interior.”➕
“I hate it so much, lol.”➕
“Mine is also plastic, it's why I asked.”➕
Unclear temperature control and display
“the temp doesn't change so you don't know if it's 100 degrees or 200 degrees and your product is burning.”➕
Electrical reliability issues (fuse failures)
“Same thing happened to me.”➕
“Magic mill uses a crap fuse.”➕
Limited accessory options for fruit leather trays
“I ended up just getting a different dehydrator. I got an Excalibur. Much easier to use.”➕
“I found this today.”➕
Concerns about reliability (stops working within weeks)
“There are a lot of reviews saying it just stops working after a couple weeks?”➕
Slow temperature recovery under load
“the temperature in the dehydrator is only 135°F. It is rising, but only very slowly.”➕
“Mine doesn't reach temp till like 4 hours into the batch and is a higher wattage.”➕
“The Magic Mill only has 600 watts, and for 10 trays that's not a lot of heating power.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
PSIIDAN Food Dehydrator Machine, 12-Trays Stainless Steel Digital Food DryerPSIIDAN Food Dehydrator Machine, 12-Trays Stainless Steel Digital Food Dryer$199
9.1
DetailsBuy
COSORI Food Dehydrator, Bigger Than 7 Trays with 600W PowerCOSORI Food Dehydrator, Bigger Than 7 Trays with 600W Power$159
9.0
DetailsBuy
COSORI Food Dehydrator Machine for JerkyCOSORI Food Dehydrator Machine for Jerky$49
8.0
DetailsBuy
YASHE Food Dehydrator MachineYASHE Food Dehydrator Machine$49
7.8
DetailsBuy
OSTBA Food Dehydrator, Dehydrator for Food and JerkyOSTBA Food Dehydrator, Dehydrator for Food and Jerky$49
7.3
DetailsBuy
Cercker Food-Dehydrator Machine 8 Stainless Steel TraysCercker Food-Dehydrator Machine 8 Stainless Steel Trays$100
6.9
DetailsBuy
Septree Commercial Food Dehydrator 18 TraysSeptree Commercial Food Dehydrator 18 Trays$399
6.9
DetailsBuy
Elite Gourmet EFD319 Food DehydratorElite Gourmet EFD319 Food Dehydrator$39
6.0
DetailsBuy
Magic Mill Pro Food Dehydrator MachineMagic Mill Pro Food Dehydrator Machine$139
5.9
DetailsBuy
Elite Gourmet Digital Food DehydratorElite Gourmet Digital Food Dehydrator$39
5.1
DetailsBuy
Magic Mill Food Dehydrator MachineMagic Mill Food Dehydrator Machine$54
5.0
DetailsBuy
Hamilton Beach Digital Food Dehydrator for Fruit and JerkyHamilton Beach Digital Food Dehydrator for Fruit and Jerky$76
4.9
DetailsBuy
Nesco FD-75A Snackmaster Pro Food DehydratorNesco FD-75A Snackmaster Pro Food Dehydrator$88
4.8
DetailsBuy
Homdox Food Dehydrator MachineHomdox Food Dehydrator Machine$69
3.9
DetailsBuy
ROVRAk Commercial Dehydrator Machine, 16-Tray Food DehydratorROVRAk Commercial Dehydrator Machine, 16-Tray Food Dehydrator$278
3.6
DetailsBuy
Konfintos Food Dehydrator for JerkyKonfintos Food Dehydrator for Jerky$49
3.4
DetailsBuy
HOPERAN Food DehydratorHOPERAN Food Dehydrator$117
1.4
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Fakespot analysis bot mention
“Fakespot detects fake reviews, fake products and unreliable sellers using AI.”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Creative food preparation techniques (e.g. caramelizing onions and using mason jars)
“They taste great.”➕
“You might be a genius. I'm doing this!”➕
“Good luck with the project!”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Attractive pricing and discount offers influence purchase decisions
“Deciding factor because I was looking at both of these too, was that it had a $50.00 off coupon.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Unusual odor retention observed in dehydrator use
“yes it did smell of onions for quite a while.”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Waffle Irons
Top Waffle Irons for Perfect Breakfasts
Top Waffle Irons for Perfect Breakfasts
Explore Waffle Irons
Hand Blenders
The Best Hand Blenders for Your Kitchen
The Best Hand Blenders for Your Kitchen
Explore Hand Blenders
Countertop Blenders
Top Countertop Blenders for Every Home Kitchen
Top Countertop Blenders for Every Home Kitchen
Explore Countertop Blenders