Olde Thompson Since 1944 Hotel Pepper Mill, 17" Walnut

Curated from 35 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 16, 2025

Olde Thompson Since 1944 Hotel Pepper Mill, 17" Walnut

Brand: Olde Thompson Since 1944
Price: $32
Snoop Score:
1.1
Sentiment
0.0
Popularity
0.0
Technical
1.9

Snoop's Take

Olde Thompson Since 1944 Hotel Pepper Mill is a 17-inch walnut-stained, hand-turned professional-quality pepper grinder designed for both home kitchens and commercial settings. It offers fully adjustable grind settings to cater to your culinary needs with style and functionality. User feedback, however, paints a less flattering picture with accounts of the grinder failing under casual use. One reviewer lamented that the 'pepper grinder broke mid twist over my roommate’s mac & cheese,' a sardonic nod to its fragility in real-life kitchen skirmishes. Despite its appealing aesthetics and adjustable design, repeated claims about durability issues have users questioning its long-term viability. In conclusion, while the product stands out aesthetically and in design, its performance is significantly marred by durability concerns, making it a dubious recommendation for users in need of a robust, long-term solution in their kitchens.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Pepper Mills

Question why is cracked pepper never offered or thought to put on a pizza?

Insightful Chatter

pepper grinder broke mid twist over my roommate’s mac & cheese.

Negative Feedback
Product
1.1
Olde Thompson Since 1944 Hotel Pepper Mill, 17" Walnut
Everyday Cooking
2 / 10
Gourmet Dining
2 / 10
Entertaining
2 / 10
Gift Giving
2 / 10
See how this compares to all Pepper Mills

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Durability issues during use
pepper grinder broke mid twist over my roommate’s mac & cheese.
Now it’s just cacio e (molto) pepe

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
MANNKITCHEN Pepper Cannon - Professional Grade Pepper MillMANNKITCHEN Pepper Cannon - Professional Grade Pepper Mill$159
9.6
DetailsBuy
Peugeot - Paris u'Select Manual Pepper MillPeugeot - Paris u'Select Manual Pepper Mill$42
7.6
DetailsBuy
Cole & Mason Derwent Pepper Grinder - Stainless SteelCole & Mason Derwent Pepper Grinder - Stainless Steel$39
7.5
DetailsBuy
Peugeot Paris u'Select Manual Pepper MillPeugeot Paris u'Select Manual Pepper Mill$45
6.5
DetailsBuy
OXO Good Grips Mess-Free Pepper Grinder, Stainless SteelOXO Good Grips Mess-Free Pepper Grinder, Stainless Steel$23
6.0
DetailsBuy
OXO Good Grips Pepper Mill with Rotating HandleOXO Good Grips Pepper Mill with Rotating Handle$14
5.9
DetailsBuy
Alexander Home The Original European MillAlexander Home The Original European Mill$80
5.4
DetailsBuy
HOME EC Original Stainless Steel Salt or Pepper GrinderHOME EC Original Stainless Steel Salt or Pepper Grinder$9
4.3
DetailsBuy
S & C Living Wooden Pepper Mill or Salt MillS & C Living Wooden Pepper Mill or Salt Mill$14
3.9
DetailsBuy
Gulex Electric Pepper Grinder or Salt MillGulex Electric Pepper Grinder or Salt Mill$9
3.0
DetailsBuy
UNIOVC Wooden Pepper Grinder Pepper MillUNIOVC Wooden Pepper Grinder Pepper Mill$18
2.8
DetailsBuy
OXO Good Grips Contoured Mess-Free Pepper GrinderOXO Good Grips Contoured Mess-Free Pepper Grinder$17
2.6
DetailsBuy
PepperMate Traditional Black Pepper Grinder MillPepperMate Traditional Black Pepper Grinder Mill$39
2.6
DetailsBuy
Gulex Wood Pepper Grinder Pepper MillGulex Wood Pepper Grinder Pepper Mill$7
1.5
DetailsBuy
Olde Thompson Since 1944 Hotel Pepper Mill, 17" WalnutOlde Thompson Since 1944 Hotel Pepper Mill, 17" Walnut$32
1.1
DetailsBuy

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Discussion on pizza seasoning preferences
Question why is cracked pepper never offered or thought to put on a pizza?
Because crushed red pepper flake is the move
Unique and addictive.
I do use salt/ pepper in my sauce.
Discussion on Olde Thompson Umami seasoning
the new Olde Thompson Umami at costco taste exactly the same for less than half the price.
I go through one of these a month at TJs so I will be checking my Costco for them this weekend!
How do you use it? Any recipe suggestions??
I haven't seen it in my local store and I'd like to find out if/when it's coming in!

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Corkscrews & Openers
Top Corkscrew & Wine Opener Tools for Home & Hospitality
Top Corkscrew & Wine Opener Tools for Home & Hospitality
Manual
Best Manual Can Openers for Your Home Kitchen
Best Manual Can Openers for Your Home Kitchen
Pasta Makers & Accessories
Top Pasta Maker Accessories for Your Home Kitchen
Top Pasta Maker Accessories for Your Home Kitchen