PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar for Dogs

Curated from 52 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 30, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6

PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar for Dogs

Brand: PetSafe
Price: $39
Snoop Score:
5.3
Sentiment
4.1
Popularity
6.3
Technical
5.2
Buy on Amazon for $39See All Bark Collars Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar is an automatic anti-bark training device designed for dogs weighing 8 lb and up. It features adjustable static correction levels and a safety shutoff mechanism to ensure your dog's well-being while effectively reducing excessive barking. Consumer feedback highlights its effectiveness for stubborn dogs, with one user remarking, "there was an immediate difference and we could walk past other dogs without a reaction." However, concerns have been raised regarding the collar's impact on multiple dogs and humane treatment, with critics stating, "bark collars are virtually always made to be aversive because that's how you suppress the barking." Despite mixed reviews, many pet owners found it beneficial in managing their dog's barking behavior. Overall, the PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar is recommended for dog owners seeking a solution for excessive barking, especially for stubborn breeds. However, potential buyers should consider both the positive and negative feedback to ensure it aligns with their training philosophy.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Bark Collars

my stubborn coonhound mix that sometimes just barks at the air for like 15 minutes.

Positive Feedback

It is especially ineffective/unkind if there are more than one dog present and the non-collared dog is getting sprayed when the collared dog barks.

Negative Feedback
Product
5.3
PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar for Dogs
Buy on Amazon for $39
Nighttime Bark Control
5 / 10
Large & Small Dogs
8 / 10
Water & Outdoor Activities
8 / 10
Progressive Behavior Training
2 / 10
See how this compares to all Bark Collars

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Effective for stubborn dogs
“my stubborn coonhound mix that sometimes just barks at the air for like 15 minutes.”➕
“We got the same for our 2 small hugs and worked quite well,”➕
“I never want my dog to be left with something that has any graduation to possibily shock.”➕
“she barks at any noise but given our current situation that is a major issue.”➕
Effective in reducing excessive barking
“the dog was a little shut beast with a high pitched bark you could hear even inside its house.”➕
“Bark collars work but dog owners are idiots and won't use them half the time because they don't care about other people.”➕
Effective for reducing excessive barking
“If I don't get this barking under control, I am seriously going to lose it.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Considered ineffective and unkind for multiple dogs
“It is especially ineffective/unkind if there are more than one dog present and the non-collared dog is getting sprayed when the collared dog barks.”➕
“They're completely ineffective (once a dog barks and they are sprayed with citronella, they experience discomfort for a long time... so they continue to be "punished" even if they've long since stopped barking) and are not "humane" by any stretch of the imagination.”➕
“Bark collars are virtually always made to be aversive because that how you suppress the barking.”➕
“I resolved my dog's barking through counterconditioning and desensitization, along with some white noise to reduce the triggers.”➕
Concerns about the humane treatment of barking dogs
“Thoughts on bark collars? I have seen two sides to using this.”➕
“You should not train your dog to never bark. You should train your dog to shut up when you want him to.”➕
“I've seen slight suppression signs after bark collar use in a dog who tolerated any other training tools without a blink.”➕
“We finally found a humane solution! A citronella bark collar! The collar stays on the dog when in a barking situation and emits a spray of citronella when he barks and it works!!”➕
Bark collars may not stop all barking
“It doesn’t stop all barking but it keeps the barking frenzy from being directly next to my fence.”➕
Concerns about the safety and humane treatment of dogs
“Radio Systems has for years concealed the harsh truth about Shock Collar Products.”➕
“I could never bring myself to use anything other than the vibrate or beep functions.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
Vuicl 3 Pack Dog Bark CollarVuicl 3 Pack Dog Bark Collar$59
8.6
DetailsBuy
DINJOO Dog Bark CollarDINJOO Dog Bark Collar$33
8.2
DetailsBuy
FAFAFROG Dog Bark Collar for All Dog SizesFAFAFROG Dog Bark Collar for All Dog Sizes$37
7.8
DetailsBuy
PRTRFLC Dog Bark Collar for Large Medium DogsPRTRFLC Dog Bark Collar for Large Medium Dogs$24
7.8
DetailsBuy
SKBAK Dog Bark Collar - Rechargeable Anti Barking DeviceSKBAK Dog Bark Collar - Rechargeable Anti Barking Device$59
7.6
DetailsBuy
PaiPaitek Bark Activated Shock Collar with RemotePaiPaitek Bark Activated Shock Collar with Remote$38
7.6
DetailsBuy
CZCCWD Rechargeable Dog Bark CollarCZCCWD Rechargeable Dog Bark Collar$38
7.4
DetailsBuy
NUFFLOFF Dog Bark Collar - Automatic Anti Barking CollarNUFFLOFF Dog Bark Collar - Automatic Anti Barking Collar$19
7.3
DetailsBuy
Pituau Dog Bark Collar 2 PackPituau Dog Bark Collar 2 Pack$35
6.9
DetailsBuy
Nhilvyg 2 Pack Bark Collar for DogsNhilvyg 2 Pack Bark Collar for Dogs$28
6.7
DetailsBuy
IHE Smart Dog Bark CollarIHE Smart Dog Bark Collar$79
6.6
DetailsBuy
SEDULAN Bark Collar 2 Pack for DogsSEDULAN Bark Collar 2 Pack for Dogs$27
6.4
DetailsBuy
ELECANE Tiny Bark Collar for Small DogsELECANE Tiny Bark Collar for Small Dogs$23
6.4
DetailsBuy
Pewkim Bark Collar for Small Medium DogsPewkim Bark Collar for Small Medium Dogs$15
6.2
DetailsBuy
DINJOO Bark Collar for DogsDINJOO Bark Collar for Dogs$35
6.1
DetailsBuy
SLAYKAM Bark Collar for Small Medium DogsSLAYKAM Bark Collar for Small Medium Dogs$28
5.9
DetailsBuy
DogRook Dog Bark CollarDogRook Dog Bark Collar$29
5.7
DetailsBuy
SLAYKAM Bark Collar for DogsSLAYKAM Bark Collar for Dogs$36
5.6
DetailsBuy
Educator BP-504 Bark-Less Pro Anti Bark CollarEducator BP-504 Bark-Less Pro Anti Bark Collar$109
5.5
DetailsBuy
PetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar for DogsPetSafe Basic Bark Control Collar for Dogs$39
5.3
DetailsBuy
NQQHNN Smart Dog Bark CollarNQQHNN Smart Dog Bark Collar$29
4.6
DetailsBuy
Colofrog 2-in-1 Dog Shock Collar & Dog Bark CollarColofrog 2-in-1 Dog Shock Collar & Dog Bark Collar$59
4.4
DetailsBuy
NBJU Bark Collar for DogsNBJU Bark Collar for Dogs$32
3.9
DetailsBuy
SportDOG Brand NoBark 10 CollarSportDOG Brand NoBark 10 Collar$69
3.8
DetailsBuy
STOPWOOFER New 2025 Dog Bark CollarSTOPWOOFER New 2025 Dog Bark Collar$34
3.0
DetailsBuy
NOIDECE Dog Bark Collar for Large Medium DogsNOIDECE Dog Bark Collar for Large Medium Dogs$24
2.8
DetailsBuy

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Distraction training techniques shared
“Distraction training is key here.”➕
“Identify what triggers the bark and counter it with a better funnier way, whenever s/he don’t bark, just rufs s/he gets praises and treats until no more bark, as other says is good to treat the No/finger gesture so s/he understands that this is not acceptable”➕
“One of mine goes crazy if there is no background noise for her. So, music or the TV is always on lol.”➕
“We did get to the point all I had to do is snap and point my finger at her. Well, it worked some of the time lol”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Suggestions for higher-end bark collars
“there are some high end models that use vibration or accelerometers to better distinguish a bark that came from the dog wearing the collar.”➕
“You would like a collar that is simultaneously capable of shocking but also not capable of shocking?”➕
Views on training dogs to bark less
“I agree with this! I started working on the quiet command with him and he listens! When he wants😂 but we are slowly getting better”➕
Discussion on various training methods and solutions for barking
“She won't do anything if I don't have a piece of food in my hand. She's bribe-able, but not biddable! Treats are like a paycheck.”➕
“Use treats. They aren't bribes, they're rewards for a job well done and an important tool for communicating what you want from your dog.”➕
“I love this little dog very much, even if I am extremely annoyed and frustrated. She's a lover and a cuddler.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Concerns about punishment for vocal dogs
“Punishment for being vocal is kind of sad.”➕
“For many animals the vibrate is much more aversive than most low levels of e-stim available on collars.”➕
“Shock collars sometimes will help with a problem, but can cause more problems and we have better ways to train dogs nowadays.”➕
“I’d recommend against anything that punishes the dog for a behavior and recommend training the “quiet” command as well as doing a calming protocol.”➕
Concerns about the humane treatment of barking dogs
“How would you like it if you were talking and someone just sprayed something irritating in your face because they wanted you to stop?”➕
Debate on the use of bark collars and alternatives
“I have never seen/heard someone whose opinion on dog training i actually respect encourage the use of a bark collar.”➕
“I encourage doing what is best to ensure the dogs needs are met, they are happy, loved, themselves and others are safe.”➕
“She used it when she wasn’t home until she was done working on the barking issue.”➕
Discussion on neighbor's dog barking issues
“I’m tired of constant dog barking no matter where I live, and this could make a huge difference”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Bark Collars
Best Smart Dog Bark Control Collars
Best Smart Dog Bark Control Collars
Explore Bark Collars