SEO Link List

automotive & industrial

Brake Tools

Bumper Stickers, Decals & Magnets

Bumpers & Bumper Accessories

Cleaning & Maintenance

Diagnostic, Test & Measurement Tools

Engine Tools

Exterior

Exterior Care

Finishing

Gaskets

Glass Care

Window & Door Seal Lubricants

Hood Scoops & Vents

Horns & Accessories

Ignition & Electrical

Interior

Interior Care

Jump Starters, Battery Chargers & Portable Power

Lighting & Electrical

Mirrors & Parts

Plumbing

Pullers

Puller Sets

Running Boards & Steps

Safety

Shocks, Struts & Suspension

Snow & Ice

Ice Scrapers & Snow Brushes

Steering & Suspension Tools

Thread Repair Kits

Spark Plug Thread Repair Kits

Tires

Tools & Equipment

Detailing Tools

Towing Products & Winches

Trailer Accessories

Stabilizer Jacks

Truck Bed & Tailgate Accessories

baby products

Activity & Entertainment

Apparel & Accessories

Baby & Toddler Toys

Baby Care

Car Seats & Accessories

Diapering

Feeding

Gifts

Nursery

Potty Training

Safety

Strollers & Accessories

Travel Gear

beauty & personal care

Foot, Hand & Nail Care

Hair Care

Makeup

Personal Care

electronics

Camera & Photo

Car & Vehicle Electronics

Cell Phones & Accessories

Computers & Accessories

Home Audio

Household Batteries, Chargers & Accessories

Television & Video

Video Game Consoles & Accessories

Headsets

Wearable Technology

health & household

Baby & Child Care

Health Care

House Supplies

Oral Care

Personal Care

Sexual Wellness

Sports Nutrition

Testosterone Boosters

Wellness & Relaxation

home & kitchen

Bath

Bedding

Heating, Cooling & Air Quality

Kitchen & Dining

Lighting & Ceiling Fans

Seasonal Decor

Outdoor Nativity Scenes

Storage & Organization

Vacuums & Floor Care

office products

Educational Supplies

Angled Paintbrushes

Office & School Supplies

patio, lawn & garden

Gardening & Lawn Care

Outdoor Decor

Outdoor Heating & Cooling

Outdoor Lighting

Outdoor Power Tools

Patio Furniture & Accessories

Decorative Pillows

Pest Control

Foggers

pet supplies

Birds

Cats

Dogs

Fish & Aquatic Pets

Horses

Reptiles & Amphibians

toys & games

Arts & Crafts

Collectible Toys

Dolls & Accessories

Strollers

Dress Up & Pretend Play

Games & Accessories

Kids' Electronics

Puppets & Puppet Theaters

Hand Puppets

Puzzles

Remote & App Controlled Vehicles & Parts

Cars

Sports & Outdoor Play

Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys

Tricycles, Scooters & Wagons

Vehicles

Physicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner - Ultra Black

Curated from 85 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: April 27, 2024

Physicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner - Ultra Black

Brand: Physicians Formula

Price: $8

Snoop Score:

2.9

Sentiment

5.7

Popularity

6.6

Technical

0.7

Buy on Amazon for $8 See All Eyeliner Reviews

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

Physicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner is a precision liquid liner designed to deliver ultra-black, waterproof performance while also nurturing lashes with its unique Lash-Boosting Complex. It promises versatile looks ranging from delicate everyday lines to bold, dramatic wings in just a few effortless strokes. Community feedback is as sharp as the brush tip itself—with many users exclaiming, “The brush is my absolute favorite; it does exactly what I want it to and puts liner exactly where I want it,” while others laud its ability to withstand emotional moments (yes, even crying at weddings). Despite high praise for its pigmentation and precision, dissenters note concerns such as uneven pigmentation and a formula that can get a bit gummy over time. Overall, the chatter oscillates between ardent recommendation and cautious critique. Bottom-line: This eyeliner is generally recommended for its standout precision and waterproof formulation, though potential buyers should be aware of occasional inconsistencies that have sparked debate among its users.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Eyeliner

The brush is my absolute favorite; it does exactly what I want it to and puts liner exactly where I want it.
Positive Feedback

Definitely no way close to brown.
Negative Feedback

2.9

Physicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner - Ultra Black

Buy on Amazon for $8

Everyday Wear

6 / 10

Special Events

6 / 10

Active Lifestyles

6 / 10

Quick Application & Touch-Ups

9 / 10

See how this compares to all Eyeliner

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.

Favorite brush tip for precise application

“The brush is my absolute favorite; it does exactly what I want it to and puts liner exactly where I want it.”➕

“Super black doesn’t rub etc.”➕

Always black and never smudgy

“Always black, never smudgy, and the micro tip makes it really easy for me.”➕

High-end feel for a drugstore product

“One of the few drugstore products I have that feels high end.”➕

Easy to achieve sharp winged eyeliner

“it bleeds like crazy when I apply it, so no matter how sharp my wing is, it ends up looking fuzzy.”➕

Good performance in crying situations

“Made it through crying at a wedding. :)”➕

Preferred brush tip for control

“I also greatly prefer the brush tip pen liner over felt, I have more even control.”➕

Solid recommendation for brown version

“the physicians formula liner in brown is pretty good!”➕

Highly pigmented compared to premium brands

“it’s blacker than a lot of premium brands.”➕

Effective even in humid conditions

“I’m a hardcore “this is the only liquid liner I like” person and I haven’t had that problem when I switched to the waterproof (damn humidity!!).”➕

Considered a holy grail liquid eyeliner

“physicians formula DOES make my holy grail liquid eyeliner tho, it’s one of the ones with a little like, jar and a long handled brush.”➕

Nice color and formula in non-waterproof version

“This is only water proof in a different universe where the laws of physics are different.”➕

Favorite eyeliner for ease of use

“Easiest Liquid Liner I’ve Ever Used!!”➕

“it’s my fave!”➕

Highly recommended for its appearance

“Holy crap I am going to go buy some of that tomorrow lol your eyeliner looks great!”➕

Rich color and precision

“This was my favorite liner because of it's rich color and precision.”➕

Favorite for ease of use and precision

“Best/Worst of Physicians Formula. After giving them up 2 years ago, I recently found out they're cru”➕

“I love how thin and precise of a line you can get with it.”➕

“That shit doesn't budge, and I've found it very easy to work with.”➕

“Only one or two swipes needed to get it to the right black!”➕

Effective when stored upside down

“I definitely second the suggestion to store it upside down.”➕

Highly recommended for felt-tipped eyeliner

“I bought their felt-tipped eyeliner and swear by it, it's incredible as a liner.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.

Inconsistent pigmentation in some batches

“Definitely no way close to brown.”➕

“I usually don't have to shake a liner for THAT long for it to come out pigmented.”➕

Concerns about cruelty-free status

“Since they're not cruelty free anymore :/.”➕

“Boo!”➕

Sheer gray color and poor flow

“Oh my god I hate this eyeliner so much. The "ink" is totally sheer gray, IF I can get any out at all!”➕

Worst eyeliner resulted in a return

“it was the worst eyeliner I had ever used. One of the only makeup products I have ever returned.”➕

Inconsistent ink flow after a few uses

“usually on my third use, i find it to become kind of patchy and the ink doesn't flow through as well.”➕

“It's like the brush gets gummy.”➕

Can appear watery and requires multiple applications

“It actually tends to come out kind of watery black over my eyeshadow and it takes multiple applications for me to get it really dark :/”➕

Can ball up if layered too much

“i do love it as a pretty good dupe for tattoo liner but i find that it kind of balls up if you go over it more than once to create a super dark line.”➕

Potential confusion between black and ultra black

“Is it possible you got 'black' and not 'ultra black'? I've heard there's a real difference.”➕

Quality decrease reported in the new formula

“I think they changed the formula!”➕

“That's a huge quality decrease.”➕

“the pigmentation is significantly weaker in the newer version.”➕

“This is the first liquid eyeliner that I planned on repurchasing.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product Name	Price	Score	See Details	Buy Now
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner - Black	$2	8.2	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner Pencil	$6	7.8	Details	Buy
L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Original Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner	$7	7.7	Details	Buy
e.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner	$5	7.6	Details	Buy
COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Liquid Eyeliner, Black Onyx	$6	7.1	Details	Buy
REVLON ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner	$7	7.0	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner	$8	7.0	Details	Buy
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Black	$5	6.8	Details	Buy
COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil, Black Onyx	$6	6.8	Details	Buy
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil Brown Denim	$6	6.7	Details	Buy
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner	$2	6.5	Details	Buy
Too Faced Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Eyeliner	$26	6.5	Details	Buy
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil	$5	6.4	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Master Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Defining Black	$8	6.2	Details	Buy
wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Baby's Got Black	$0	6.1	Details	Buy
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Brown, Vegan Formula	$9	5.9	Details	Buy
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner 001 Black	$4	5.5	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner, Ebony Black, 0.01 Ounce	$6	5.4	Details	Buy
L'Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner Black	$8	4.7	Details	Buy
Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Brown Topaz	$6	4.6	Details	Buy
e.l.f. Liquid Eyeliner, Jet Black	$3	4.6	Details	Buy
L'Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner	$7	4.2	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner	$7	4.1	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE New York Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Waterproof Eyeliner, Pitch Brown	$8	3.9	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner, Blackest Black	$8	3.9	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Brown Eyeliner Pencil	$6	3.7	Details	Buy
COVERGIRL Ink It By Perfect Point Plus Waterproof Eyeliner	$14	3.5	Details	Buy
e.l.f. Eyeliner Pen with FeltTip Applicator, Black	$3	3.1	Details	Buy
MAYBELLINE Define-A-Line Eyeliner, Brownish Black	$5	2.9	Details	Buy
Physicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner - Ultra Black	$8	2.9	Details	Buy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.

Discussion about preferences for brown eyeliners

“i find that the brown formula isn’t as good as the black in many brands.”➕

“Clinique's brown liquid liner to the reject list; it's way too light.”➕

Storing eyeliner tip down may improve performance

“remember to store it tip down in like a cup!”➕

“Holy shit that never even crossed my mind to store it like that.”➕

“Yay! Simple solutions!”➕

Discussion about lash fiber technology

“A little feathery, but they look pretty darn close to real lashes that just happen to be luscious.”➕

“it's interesting how different techniques and products work.”➕

Discussion about changes in eyeliner formula

“Which is the new and which is the old formula in the picture?”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.

Suggestions for alternatives to liquid eyeliner

“I personally find it wears much better and it's a lot more comfortable bc it's flexible and "soft" even when set vs pen formulas which feel dry and usually end up flaking on me.”➕

Using water to unclog the brush tip

“Sounds stupid but it worked for me!”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’

Comparison to other brands

“I had to finally call it and go back to Stila. Nothing I tried could even compare.”➕

“I really like the Anastasia liquid liner!”➕

“I used Lancôme artliner for years which was pretty good.”➕

Comparison to drugstore eyeliners

“It has really good staying power for my super oily eyelids, but it seems to move out the way if I try to do another line or put anything on top.”➕

“Wet and wild breakup proof liner”➕

“The waterproof liquid eyeliner from essence is good.”➕

Comparison with other brands' eyeliners

“I like NYX epic ink liner but the last two I bought leaked badly.”➕

“Both are comparable to Physician's Formula I would say!”➕

“I like it better than NYX Epic Ink and Stila Stay All Day.”➕

“The formula drys faster than others I've tried which is good to help prevent feathering.”➕

Discussion about similar gel eyeliner alternatives

“I used to love this formula, it was almost like a whipped texture and went on so easily.”➕

“I loooooove them. But seriously, PF, bring these back.”➕

“I like tons of their other stuff already.”➕

“It is tenacious and looks as good at the end of the day as when you first put it on.”➕

User experiences with different eyeliner versions

“It's straight up brown. I'm going to return it.”➕

Seeking alternatives to Physicians Formula eyeliner

“Essence is cruelty free & has a great one! Super last eyeliner & it is cheap!”➕

“I guess that’s good for wear but I hate having to mess with my eyes so much trying to remove it.”➕

Alternatives to Physicians Formula eyeliner

“Jesse's girl eyeliner. I buy it at Rite Aid.”➕

“Elf eyeliner is unbelievable.”➕

“Wet n Wild felt tip eyeliner is incredible for like $3!!!”➕

General thoughts on other Physicians Formula products

“Best by far I've tried is their Butter Bronzer. It SMELLS AMAZING! Like pina coladas and coconuts and sunscreen.”➕

“I second the Butter Bronzer; it honestly lives up to the hype.”➕

Discussion about discounting of Physicians Formula products at CVS

“I'm a fan. (Mostly because I always get them for cheap at CVS, but I've really fallen in love with their mineral makeup.)”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.

Discussion about potential clogging issues

“I remember being told that when a product picks itself back up like that, it's because there's too much oil on your skin and the product can't grab on.”➕