Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker

Name: Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker
Price: 199.99 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5.2 (96 reviews)

Curated from 96 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 27, 2025

Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker

Brand: Mr. Coffee

Price: $199

Snoop Score:

5.2

Sentiment

6.3

Popularity

9.7

Technical

3.5

Buy on Amazon for $199 See All Iced Tea Machines Reviews

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker is designed to simplify the process of brewing iced tea at home, allowing users to enjoy refreshing beverages with ease. Many customers appreciate its durable construction, with one user noting, "My family has used the standard Mr. Coffee one forever and have only needed one replacement in the 30+ years of my memory," showcasing its longevity. While it excels in convenience with features like a tea bag holder and the ability to brew larger quantities, some users have expressed dissatisfaction with the flavor, mentioning issues like watered-down tea and the need for better coffee brands. Overall, the Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker is recommended for those looking for a reliable tea brewing solution, but potential buyers should be aware of the mixed feedback regarding taste and durability.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Iced Tea Machines

My family has used the standard Mr. Coffee one forever and have only needed one replacement in the 30+ years of my memory.
Positive Feedback

Anyone having luck actually making a decent iced coffee with this? All mine taste so watered down with no flavor.
Negative Feedback

5.2

Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker

Buy on Amazon for $199

Entertaining Guests

2 / 10

Daily Refreshment

3 / 10

Cold Brew Coffee

4 / 10

Flavor Experimentation

3 / 10

See how this compares to all Iced Tea Machines

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.

Durable and long-lasting

“My family has used the standard Mr. Coffee one forever and have only needed one replacement in the 30+ years of my memory.”➕

Decent results with adjustments

“It's been decent in my experience.”➕

“Love mine! Maybe bigger ice cubes?”➕

Convenient tea bag holder

“Mr. Coffee maker has a helpful spot to hold your tea bags under the lid.”➕

“I make a pot of tea at a time and just found that the tag on my teas bag fit perfectly in the handle under the lid.”➕

Great for making iced tea regularly

“I like iced tea, I want to try good loose tea. With an iced tea maker.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.

Watered down flavor

“Anyone having luck actually making a decent iced coffee with this? All mine taste so watered down with no flavor.”➕

Need for better coffee brands

“Get a better brand of coffee that would be my suggestion”➕

Mr. Coffee has poor build quality and reliability

“They stop working after about 3 months of daily use”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product Name	Price	Score	See Details	Buy Now
Sunvivi Iced Tea Maker with 3-Quart Pitcher	$39	8.1	Details	Buy
West Bend IT500-W Coffee Iced Tea Maker	$31	7.0	Details	Buy
wirsh Iced Tea Maker with 3QT Pitcher	$59	6.8	Details	Buy
LITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing System	$59	6.6	Details	Buy
AEMEGO Iced Tea Maker	$61	6.4	Details	Buy
Brentwood KT-2150BK Iced Tea and Coffee Maker	$51	6.2	Details	Buy
Mr. Coffee 2-Quart Iced Tea & Iced Coffee Maker	$155	6.1	Details	Buy
OVENTE 3-Quart Iced Tea and Coffee Maker	$55	6.1	Details	Buy
LITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing System	$49	5.7	Details	Buy
Mr. Coffee 3-Quart Iced Tea and Iced Coffee Maker	$198	5.7	Details	Buy
Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker	$199	5.2	Details	Buy
Blomus Jay Iced Tea Maker	$73	5.2	Details	Buy
Takeya Flash Chill Iced Tea Maker	$27	4.7	Details	Buy
Capresso 623.02 Select Iced Tea Maker	$49	4.7	Details	Buy
Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System	$39	4.5	Details	Buy
Mr. Coffee TM3 Iced Tea Maker	$199	4.3	Details	Buy
Brentwood KT-2121 Single-Serve Iced Coffee and Tea Maker	$33	4.0	Details	Buy
Homecraft Electric Iced Tea Maker	$27	3.9	Details	Buy
Home Hero Cold Brew Coffee Maker with Heavy Duty Glass Body & 2 Lids	$24	3.8	Details	Buy
HomeCheer Cold Brew Coffee Maker 64 oz (2 Quart)	$38	3.6	Details	Buy
BUNN TB3Q 3-Gallon Iced Tea Brewer	$807	2.2	Details	Buy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.

Nostalgic reference to 90s design

“Mr. Coffee automatic iced tea maker and pitcher, circa 1995”➕

Personal memories associated with the product

“My mom made our tea with this!”➕

Reference to past Mr. Coffee tea products

“You missed Mrs. Tea by Mr. Coffee! Also, they make terrible tea -- they're essentially just a Mr. Coffee with a teapot instead of a coffee carafe, you even use coffee filters!”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.

Possibility of using a French press for iced tea

“Yes you can. I have used a French press to make cold brew tea before”➕

Creative brewing methods

“I usually work a gallon ahead.”➕

“Don't ice it. Stick it in the fridge overnight instead.”➕

“I just have an electric kettle. I do it like you do, instead of adding a bunch of ice I just get two rounds of hot water, pour it into a pitcher, then add my tea bag for maybe 10 minutes, remove the tea, depending on the kind of tea I might stir in some honey while it's hot and then sit it on the counter to cool off and smell good.”➕

“I boil the water in a tea kettle and pour onto the bags in a ceramic tea pot.”➕

Suggestions for alternative brewing methods

“It's a reaction between tannins and caffeine, released with heat.”➕

“I'm just gonna make iced tea from hot brew (of loose tea leaves) and not worry if it's not crystal clear.”➕

“I have luck adding a bit of boiling water to the cloudy tea.”➕

“I cold brew Yorkshire Red with Minneapolis tap water and have the best, smooth, strong iced tea every day.”➕

Idea of using the iced tea maker as a teapot

“I never thought about that, but that would make a good tea pot.”➕

Discussion on alternative tea-making methods

“So do ACTUAL iced tea makers actually exist? What terms would one use to search for them if they do?”➕

“I wonder if it would be nice to make a very strong concentrated, hot cup of tea you want then shake it with ice in a cocktail shaker and then serve it.”➕

“This is more reasons why a tea maker was considered.”➕

“Start with clean empty pitcher.”➕

Suggestions for using different types of loose leaf tea

“Uptown tea has a huge selection of loose leaf teas organized by type.”➕

“I usually use either english breakfast or gunpowder green.”➕

Discussion of alternative brewing methods

“mmm Orange Pekoe (currently drinking the K-Cup stuff from Timmies); anyway, onto the topic at hand.”➕

Alternative brewing methods suggested

“a maker costs $30 and if you press the on button before you go to sleep, it should brew cycle once the timer powers on in the morning, but there is no warming plate like a coffee maker.”➕

“Thanks for your suggestions. I'm a little confused about the first one, does that mean I would end up with a cup of iced tea?”➕

Recipe sharing for iced tea preparation

“Alright Southern Redditors, I need your best Ice Tea/Sweet Tea recipe Step by step, detailed instructions are appreciated.”➕

“I use a heaping 1/3 cup of sugar and 2 tea bags for every quart of tea.”➕

“Baking soda removes any bitterness and gives you a sparkling clear glass of iced tea!”➕

“1. Go buy an iced tea machine.”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’

Personal experiences with brewing tea

“I use tea bags. And my solution for this just ended up being buying purified drinking water by the gallon and using that to make tea.”➕

Suggestions for improving flavor

“I would add in a pot full of ice underneath mr coffee and subtract the water you add to your coffee machine in total.”➕

Comparing tea makers to coffee makers in price and functionality

“Every morning I wake up go put on the kettle, wait for it to boil, and then tea has to steep.”➕

“Electric kettle + teapot seems just as easy, if not easier, than an automatic coffee maker to me.”➕

“Coffee and water you can set up the night before and set a time for it to start, so coffee will be ready when you wake up.”➕

“Electric kettle + smart plug you can schedule to turn on.”➕

Discussion on various tea-making appliances

“Basically you put water in the pitcher and tea in the basket, and then press a button indicating what kind of tea you're making.”➕

“It has long been a dream of mine to have a gongfu-focused automated brewing device.”➕

“Most products are still in the production stage, but are rapidly improving.”➕

“Fantastic question! And the answer is yes! Most products are still in the production stage, but are ”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.

Humorous take on tea brewing

“probably, I mean it's not as if the Tea Police will smash your door down mid brew”➕

“I made this joke before but...:”➕

“100% Iced Coffee”➕

“That was good. I teared up laughing”➕

Discussion on coffee preferences and quality expectations

“Want to upgrade, willing to spend 100-500$. Not willing to invest in a Coffee maker that is too time intensive.”➕

“why is the mr. coffee not cutting it? what are you looking for in a coffee maker? what do you expect in a cup of coffee as far as quality?”➕

“Right now my quality is Aldi coffee grounds that overflow the filter into the coffee so I have grounds in my coffee every cup.”➕

“My suggestion is to get another Mr. Coffee. If caffeine is your highest priority, make a half-pot with enough grounds to taste, but not to overfill the hopper.”➕

Humorous take on tea flavor preferences

“Hey dawg Dont hate on silver needle if you can't respect the subtleties of a nice faint white tea.”➕

Discussion about tea makers and coffee makers

“Personally, I would shell out the $190 for an on sale one since it really is worth the price.”➕

Discussion of coffee preferences

“Yeah. I’m not a coffee drinker either and that would confuse me as well.”➕

Variety in coffee preferences

“Pretty much keeping taste and preference out of it, can I expect Mr.Coffee to provide reliable service?”➕

“Yes, it'll work just fine for what you're going for. If you ever wanna learn about making the best ”➕

“I just pour water over the grinds and let it filter into a cup.”➕

“Mr coffee is a good brand and makes good coffee if you are not looking for perfection.”➕

Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker

Curated from 96 real Reddit conversations

Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker

Snoop's Take

Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker

Entertaining Guests

Daily Refreshment

Cold Brew Coffee

Flavor Experimentation

What it does well!

Where it needs some work!

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Core Power Plays

Hidden Hero Hacks

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

Cautionary Callouts

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories