Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System

Curated from 119 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 13, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6

Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System

Brand: Nostalgia
Price: $39
Snoop Score:
4.5
Sentiment
0.0
Popularity
0.0
Technical
7.6
Buy on Amazon for $39See All Iced Tea Machines Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System is designed to help users easily brew a variety of refreshing beverages at home, from iced coffees and teas to flavored waters and lemonades. With a generous 3-quart capacity and a straightforward operation, this brewing system aims to deliver delicious drinks while ensuring convenience and optimal flavor extraction through its specialized features. However, consumer sentiment has highlighted some concerns regarding the product. Users have reported issues with "uncleanable mildew stains" and a noticeable "taste of plastic" in beverages, indicating potential drawbacks in terms of cleanliness and material quality. This feedback suggests that while the brewing system has potential, it may fall short in delivering a completely satisfying user experience. Given the mixed feedback, particularly regarding hygiene and taste, it may be advisable to consider alternatives within the beverage brewing category before making a purchase decision on the Nostalgia Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Iced Tea Machines

I brew maybe a gallon or so per day. I know there are other ways to make tea but I drink a lot of tea.

Insightful Chatter

That little ring of un-cleanable tea-stained mildew…

Negative Feedback
Product
4.5
Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System
Buy on Amazon for $39
Entertaining Guests
9 / 10
Daily Refreshment
5 / 10
Cold Brew Coffee
6 / 10
Flavor Experimentation
9 / 10
See how this compares to all Iced Tea Machines

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Concerns about uncleanable mildew stains
“That little ring of un-cleanable tea-stained mildew…”➕
Taste of plastic in beverages
“I can taste the plastic from here.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
Sunvivi Iced Tea Maker with 3-Quart PitcherSunvivi Iced Tea Maker with 3-Quart Pitcher$39
8.1
DetailsBuy
West Bend IT500-W Coffee Iced Tea MakerWest Bend IT500-W Coffee Iced Tea Maker$31
7.0
DetailsBuy
wirsh Iced Tea Maker with 3QT Pitcherwirsh Iced Tea Maker with 3QT Pitcher$59
6.8
DetailsBuy
LITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing SystemLITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing System$59
6.6
DetailsBuy
AEMEGO Iced Tea MakerAEMEGO Iced Tea Maker$61
6.4
DetailsBuy
Brentwood KT-2150BK Iced Tea and Coffee MakerBrentwood KT-2150BK Iced Tea and Coffee Maker$51
6.2
DetailsBuy
Mr. Coffee 2-Quart Iced Tea & Iced Coffee MakerMr. Coffee 2-Quart Iced Tea & Iced Coffee Maker$155
6.1
DetailsBuy
OVENTE 3-Quart Iced Tea and Coffee MakerOVENTE 3-Quart Iced Tea and Coffee Maker$55
6.1
DetailsBuy
LITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing SystemLITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing System$49
5.7
DetailsBuy
Mr. Coffee 3-Quart Iced Tea and Iced Coffee MakerMr. Coffee 3-Quart Iced Tea and Iced Coffee Maker$198
5.7
DetailsBuy
Mr. Coffee Iced Tea MakerMr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker$199
5.2
DetailsBuy
Blomus Jay Iced Tea MakerBlomus Jay Iced Tea Maker$73
5.2
DetailsBuy
Takeya Flash Chill Iced Tea MakerTakeya Flash Chill Iced Tea Maker$27
4.7
DetailsBuy
Capresso 623.02 Select Iced Tea MakerCapresso 623.02 Select Iced Tea Maker$49
4.7
DetailsBuy
Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing SystemNostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System$39
4.5
DetailsBuy
Mr. Coffee TM3 Iced Tea MakerMr. Coffee TM3 Iced Tea Maker$199
4.3
DetailsBuy
Brentwood KT-2121 Single-Serve Iced Coffee and Tea MakerBrentwood KT-2121 Single-Serve Iced Coffee and Tea Maker$33
4.0
DetailsBuy
Homecraft Electric Iced Tea MakerHomecraft Electric Iced Tea Maker$27
3.9
DetailsBuy
Home Hero Cold Brew Coffee Maker with Heavy Duty Glass Body & 2 LidsHome Hero Cold Brew Coffee Maker with Heavy Duty Glass Body & 2 Lids$24
3.8
DetailsBuy
HomeCheer Cold Brew Coffee Maker 64 oz (2 Quart)HomeCheer Cold Brew Coffee Maker 64 oz (2 Quart)$38
3.6
DetailsBuy
BUNN TB3Q 3-Gallon Iced Tea BrewerBUNN TB3Q 3-Gallon Iced Tea Brewer$807
2.2
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Discussion about the aesthetics of kombucha brewing
“Take a look at the iced tea machine! 🤮 I think this needs to be on the side work rotation”➕
“That looks like a straight up kombucha scoby”➕
“I love kombucha but haven’t tried to make my own bc I don’t know if I could stomach looking at the SCOBY mother.”➕
“My friend has some sitting in a jar at his house it literally looks like some shit straight out of game of thrones.”➕
Comments on the flavor and quality of coffee made at home vs. coffee shops
“It’s all the temperature that those coffee shops can do vs home machines.”➕
“The only thing starbucks got going for it is the Frappuccinos.”➕
Discussion about using less pulp for cleanliness
“Fresh squeezed juice (squeezed in house at least) is overkill.”➕
“I always strain the pulp out.”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
User shares personal iced tea brewing method
“I brew maybe a gallon or so per day. I know there are other ways to make tea but I drink a lot of tea.”➕
“No problems with over-extraction or bitterness, always great results.”➕
“Nothing is set in stone and at best these are just base recipes till you figure out what ratio and brands work for you.”➕
“Ever since I learned I never bought again.”➕
User's shift from iced tea to coffee brewing
“I’ve moved on to coffee.”➕
Discussion about various coffee-making methods and tools
“There are egg bite maker machines! I got one for Christmas! It’s like a waffle maker but for egg bites.”➕
“Yess, i love the ice forte and ice leggero because they have such a good crema.”➕
“I honestly kind of just winged it! I would put about 3 parts heavy whipping cream and one part milk in a cup.”➕
User's extensive experience with frozen drink recipes
“Finally my time to shine.”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Preference for using electric kettle over iced tea makers
“I’ve had an iced tea maker, but to me, its just easier to use an electric kettle, steep the leaves for a few minutes, and it’s done.”➕
User suggests adjusting brew timer
“Adjust the brew timer”➕
Discussion about manual and control panel complexity
“instead of putting an actual control panel they like to make a secret code with the buttons.”➕
Advice on potential calcification of water lines
“The lines could be calcified. May need to be replaced.”➕
Discussion about the cost of coffee compared to making at home
“My Nespresso machine has ruined me as a customer to all coffee shops. Vanilla iced lattes on demand.”➕
“That little thrill you get every time you make a coffee that is better than Starbucks, cheaper than Starbucks, and you made it in your jammies with bedhead.”➕
“It breaks down to like $1 per coffee it’s nuts.”➕
“I used to be a Starbucks drinker and then I got my machine for Christmas a few years ago and I’m so glad I did. It made me realize how overpriced Starbucks is and it also made me realize how bad their coffee really is.”➕
Personal experiences transitioning from Starbucks to home coffee making
“You can make really similar egg bites with a muffin tin by water bathing (think like a cheesecake!) No sous vide necessary.”➕
Discussion about convenience of homemade iced tea
“Just convenient and delicious homemade iced tea at malls, business lobbies, etc.”➕
“So your going to buy a vending machine and just stock it with your own brewed and bottled iced tea?”➕
“It’s a tough go but it’s doable if tied to the right marketing.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
User's long-term experience with a standard iced tea maker
“My family has used the standard Mr. Coffee one forever and have only needed one replacement in the 30+ years of my memory.”➕
Concerns about cleanliness of brewing equipment
“Omfg. Those are supposed to be cleaned and sanitized every single night. That is f*#*#*% *disgusting*.”➕
“Did you check the diffuser that screws on at the top? Only reason I ask is because I realized my staff wasn't taking it off to wash it and that thing was nasty”➕
User shares nostalgic iced tea experiences
“I want to see the can design again to remember it.”➕
“I never found anything even close.”➕
“nestea with the icecubes on it google images should show u or it was brisk iced tea in a can.”➕
Nostalgia for traditional iced tea brewers
“Did your mom or grandma have a Mr. Coffee tea brewer, too?”➕
“We still do! And it was my mom’s. Works great.”➕
Nostalgic memories of using the product
“Yes! Yesyesyesyeeeeeeesss. I feel like everyone I knew had these when I was a kid.”➕
“My parents had one of these for seemingly all of my youth- it was a constant in the fridge.”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Iced Tea Machines
wirsh Iced Tea Maker with 3QT Pitcher
wirsh Iced Tea Maker with 3QT Pitcher
Explore
West Bend IT500-W Coffee Iced Tea Maker
West Bend IT500-W Coffee Iced Tea Maker
Explore
LITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing System
LITIFO Iced Tea Maker and Iced Coffee Maker Brewing System
Explore
Explore more Categories
Top Electric Meat Grinders for Your Home Kitchen
Top Electric Meat Grinders for Your Home Kitchen
Explore
Top Chest Freezers for Extra Home Storage
Top Chest Freezers for Extra Home Storage
Explore
Top Stand Mixers for Your Kitchen
Top Stand Mixers for Your Kitchen
Explore