GOTHAM STEEL Nonstick Panini Press Sandwich Maker

Curated from 82 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 19, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6

GOTHAM STEEL Nonstick Panini Press Sandwich Maker

Brand: GOTHAM STEEL
Price: $19
Snoop Score:
7.5
Sentiment
8.8
Popularity
8.8
Technical
6.7
Buy on Amazon for $19See All Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The Gotham Steel Nonstick Panini Press Sandwich Maker is a versatile kitchen appliance designed to create delicious grilled sandwiches quickly and easily. With its nonstick surface and compact design, it allows users to make perfectly toasted sandwiches in under five minutes, making it ideal for busy mornings or late-night snacks. Consumer feedback highlights the product's strengths in creating crispy bread and melted cheese, with one user stating, "I have one and I love it! I use it every single day." Many users appreciate its compact design, making it easy to store and perfect for small kitchens. However, some feedback indicates that while the panini press excels at making sandwiches, it may lack the versatility of other cooking tools, with comments such as, "I think it's a waste" when compared to a George Foreman grill. Overall, the Gotham Steel Nonstick Panini Press Sandwich Maker is recommended for those seeking a simple and fun way to elevate their sandwich game, particularly for grilled cheese and other heated sandwiches, despite some concerns about versatility and cleaning difficulties.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses

They seem like a fun and easy way to make some incredible grilled sandwiches.

Positive Feedback

Yes, but get a George Foreman grill instead-- it's much more versatile than a panini press.

Negative Feedback
Product
7.5
GOTHAM STEEL Nonstick Panini Press Sandwich Maker
Buy on Amazon for $19
Quick Breakfast Sandwiches
5 / 10
Gourmet Paninis & Grilled Sandwiches
5 / 10
Multi-Function Cooking
5 / 10
Small Kitchen & Dorm Use
5 / 10
See how this compares to all Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Fun and easy way to make grilled sandwiches
“They seem like a fun and easy way to make some incredible grilled sandwiches.”➕
“Anyone here own a panini press and is it worth it? How's it changed your sandwich game overall?”➕
“Breville Smart Oven - what are we doing wrong?”➕
“Did you push the convection button? I have the same oven and food gets crispy.”➕
Great for crispy bread and melted cheese
“I think it's a great standalone tool if you like crispy bread and melted cheese in sandwiches.”➕
“Its good for crispy duck.”➕
Makes crispy bottom crust for reheated pizza
“2 slices of pizza, sandwiched on top of each other in a panini press. If that’s not stoner food, I don’t know what is.”➕
“It works great. Nice and crispy bottom crust, without that crunchy hollow outer crust that can happen when reheating pizza.”➕
Great for reheating leftovers without compromising texture
“Reheats beautifully!”➕
Great for making grilled sandwiches
“Quisinart Griddler has definitely upped my grilled cheese game.”➕
“These things are great!”➕
Compact and portable design
“Yes we had the same basket style that was amazing and gave it to a friend once we got this one 🥲”➕
“His recipes can not be followed at all, if you gonna try you have to Google a shit ton because he skips so many important steps that your hair goes gray.”➕
Daily use and satisfaction
“I have one and I love it! I use it every single day.”➕
“You can't use raw bacon though”➕
“love mine ... we actually have two of them (family of 6) ... never had any issues with them”➕
“My fiancée and I have made hundreds of delicious breakfast sandwiches with ours.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Panini press may be less versatile than other cooking tools
“Yes, but get a George Foreman grill instead-- it's much more versatile than a panini press.”➕
“Very true, you can cook ANYTHING on a George Foreman”➕
“I think it's a waste. I always have two pans heating at once for a panini: the sandwich goes in one and the second one goes on top to heat and press from the other side.”➕
“I use my George Foreman grill to make some awesome grilled sandwiches.”➕
Heating a brick for pressed sandwiches is inefficient
“I hate the idea of spending crazy amounts of energy heating up the entire oven and the brick just to make a grilled cheese.”➕
Difficult to clean
“Honestly half the time I wipe it off, close my eyes and throw the thing back in the cabinet.”➕
“How do you thoroughly clean a panini press? Dumb question but I get paranoid about these things.”➕
Produces poor sandwich quality
“Those make awful sandwiches...”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
Chefman Panini Press Grill and Sandwich MakerChefman Panini Press Grill and Sandwich Maker$39
8.5
DetailsBuy
Cuisinart Panini Press GR-4NP1Cuisinart Panini Press GR-4NP1$99
8.4
DetailsBuy
George Foreman 4-Serving Removable Plate Electric GrillGeorge Foreman 4-Serving Removable Plate Electric Grill$34
8.0
DetailsBuy
GOTHAM STEEL Nonstick Panini Press Sandwich MakerGOTHAM STEEL Nonstick Panini Press Sandwich Maker$19
7.5
DetailsBuy
OVENTE Electric Sandwich MakerOVENTE Electric Sandwich Maker$19
7.4
DetailsBuy
T-fal Compact Sandwich MakerT-fal Compact Sandwich Maker$29
7.4
DetailsBuy
IMUSA Stainless Steel Panini PressIMUSA Stainless Steel Panini Press$39
7.4
DetailsBuy
Nostalgia MyMini Personal Sandwich MakerNostalgia MyMini Personal Sandwich Maker$17
7.2
DetailsBuy
Hamilton Beach Panini Press Sandwich MakerHamilton Beach Panini Press Sandwich Maker$43
7.1
DetailsBuy
iSiLER 2 Slice Panini Press GrilliSiLER 2 Slice Panini Press Grill$49
7.0
DetailsBuy
Tasty Mini Sandwich MakerTasty Mini Sandwich Maker$16
6.9
DetailsBuy
Hamilton Beach Electric Sealed Sandwich Maker GrillHamilton Beach Electric Sealed Sandwich Maker Grill$23
6.8
DetailsBuy
Aigostar Sandwich Maker with Non-stick SurfaceAigostar Sandwich Maker with Non-stick Surface$24
6.7
DetailsBuy
ZOOFOX Sandwich MakerZOOFOX Sandwich Maker$28
6.6
DetailsBuy
JcoGel Sandwich Makers & Panini PressesJcoGel Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses$109
6.5
DetailsBuy
Breville Duo Panini PressBreville Duo Panini Press$89
6.4
DetailsBuy
Aigostar Panini Press Sandwich MakerAigostar Panini Press Sandwich Maker$31
6.4
DetailsBuy
GreenLife Pro Electric Panini Press Grill and Sandwich MakerGreenLife Pro Electric Panini Press Grill and Sandwich Maker$19
6.3
DetailsBuy
BELLA Panini Press and Sandwich MakerBELLA Panini Press and Sandwich Maker$45
6.3
DetailsBuy
Cuisinart WM-SW2N1 Sandwich GrillCuisinart WM-SW2N1 Sandwich Grill$22
6.0
DetailsBuy
Baker's Friend Panini Press Electric GriddleBaker's Friend Panini Press Electric Griddle$53
5.5
DetailsBuy
MONXOOK Electric Panini PressMONXOOK Electric Panini Press$21
1.4
DetailsBuy

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Unexpected use of panini press for non-sandwich items
“I get 30 minutes lunch break so managed to produce this meal with instant mash, sweetcorn and a dollop of blue cheese sauce.”➕
“This dude used the WORK panini press to cook a steak 😭😭😭”➕
“A lady (former co worker) decided to try reheat frozen chicken nuggets on our work panini press...”➕
“And blames "the vegans" for messing up that panini press for a subpar steak.”➕
Unexpected uses for panini press and alternatives
“Two cast iron skillets work well too.”➕
“Cast iron skillet + foil brick is all you ever need to make a great pressed sandwich.”➕
“Use the griddle as a burner on a stovetop.”➕
Alternative methods for making sandwiches
“i just use a heated heavy cast iron pan (on top) and make it work.”➕
“Hot cast iron pan > sandwich > hot cast iron pan. This is the way.”➕
Creative use of the press beyond sandwiches
“Now make a breakfast sandwich with it instead. Some of the best leftover pizzas I've ever had.”➕
Unexpected use of panini press for reheating pizza
“Another great pizza tip is to wrap your leftovers in aluminum foil and rebake them in the oven. So freaking good”➕
Curiosity about cooking with the egg sandwich maker
“And yes I can cook a sandwich perfectly on pans. but early in the morning when I have placed to be this could be a life saver”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Curiosity about workplace kitchen equipment
“Can we just pause for a second... Who's fucking work has a panini press?!”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Humor around cooking mishaps at work
“Bring a George Forman grill and show them who’s boss”➕
“Yes, a group at work would often bring in large pots/pans of food to split with one another.”➕
“Hit me with that sauerkraut meal at leaving time.”➕
“He took up the communal sandwich machine for the time it takes to cook a steak and now somebody has to clean steak grease out of it before it can be used for a sandwich again.”➕
Humor around cooking mishaps and alternative methods
“I will do it and post pics.”➕
Humor around cooking mishaps
“The Griddler sounds like a Waffle House line cook in Gotham City. Looks baller though!”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories
Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses
Best Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses
Best Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses
Explore Sandwich Makers & Panini Presses