InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal

Curated from 75 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: January 18, 2025

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal

Brand: InSinkErator

Price: $117

Snoop Score:

6.1

Sentiment

5.5

Popularity

2.5

Technical

7.6

Buy on Amazon for $117 See All Garbage Disposals Reviews

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal is a reliable and efficient food waste disposer designed to make kitchen cleanup quick and easy. Featuring a powerful 1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor, it effectively grinds everyday food scraps while minimizing noise during operation. Consumer feedback highlights its reliable performance, with many users praising its quiet operation, stating, "This thing is quiet, but be aware that the new baffle design will mean that more water will pool before draining." Additionally, the easy installation process is often noted, as one user remarked, "Installation was a breeze and it runs flawlessly." Overall, users appreciate the strong performance and the brand's longevity in the market, with some expressing loyalty to InSinkErator products due to their effectiveness. Based on user sentiment and feedback, the InSinkErator Badger 5 is recommended for those looking for a dependable and quiet garbage disposal that offers good value for money in its category.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Garbage Disposals

Insinkerator is also good.
Positive Feedback

Our Insinkerator died this weekend, it was all corroded out and let un-chopped food through into plumbing.
Negative Feedback

6.1

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal

Buy on Amazon for $117

Small Under-Sink Spaces

8 / 10

Daily Meal Preparers

7 / 10

Noise-Sensitive Homes

9 / 10

Heavy-Duty Kitchens

6 / 10

See how this compares to all Garbage Disposals

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.

Reliable performance

“Insinkerator is also good.”➕

“Functionality > Longevity > Sound”➕

Quiet operation

“This thing is quiet, but be aware that the new baffle design will mean that more water will pool before draining.”➕

“We love it and it is so so so quiet. Badgers are much louder compared to this.”➕

“Even the basic 5/8 HP is quieter than your B5 for sure.”➕

“I like my insinkerator evolution..stainless internals 3/4hp. Quiet and strong.”➕

Easy installation

“Installation was a breeze and it runs flawlessly.”➕

“works great and is quieter with less vibration than my old 1/2 horsepower unit”➕

“It has demolished everything I’ve thrown at it like it was nothing.”➕

“It’s super easy.”➕

Reliable performance over time

“Their warrantee for their Evolution 3/4hp is longer than the last 3 garbage disposals.”➕

Easy installation with plug option

“If you’ve got a plug get it with the cord. Otherwise you’ll need to wire it yourself.”➕

Easy to replace bracket during installation

“It's real easy to replace the bracket though, I'd take the extra 10 minutes and do it.”➕

“Badger and Insinkerator use a common bracket (they're the same company), the one that most KitchenAi”➕

“The bracket is part of the piece that gets inserted from above and that gets replaced real easily.”➕

Strong performance

“Strong and quiet.”➕

Preference for InSinkErator over competitors

“Stick with an insinkerator”➕

“I never get recalls with Badgers.. I like to be a loyal customer so if the product works and I'm making money, why change?”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.

Units can corrode and fail over time

“Our Insinkerator died this weekend, it was all corroded out and let un-chopped food through into plumbing.”➕

“Two plumbers have told me basically you should not use this for food scraps AT ALL.”➕

Not suitable for large food scraps

“Yep, you cannot put 5lbs of potato peels down the disposal, it just does not work.”➕

Plumbing systems can be damaged by disposals

“the more crap you put in there, the better chance of a clog.”➕

“Septics should NEVER have one added. Just scrape the plates into the trash and wipe off as much grease / oil as possible all the time.”➕

InSinkErator disposals can fail prematurely

“So... having been without a disposal for six weeks I’ve had enough and I’m just going to buy a new unit.”➕

“They are easy to swap and not that expensive, I would just assume you’ll need a new one every 5-10 years.”➕

Garbage disposals are not repairable if leaking

“They're not repairable. Get a new one and replace it.”➕

“plumber replaced as it was unrepairable”➕

Mounting brackets are not universal

“the brackets take less than 5 minutes to swap, and the new disposal comes with a new (shiny!) bracket.”➕

Difficulty with installation due to snap spring

“The hardest part of the whole job is that fucking snap spring thing that goes on the mount!”➕

Moen disposals lack breaker wrench feature

“We use them a good bit only thing I don’t like is they don’t have the breaker wrench or spot for it but other then that I think the 1/3hp also have a higher RPMs then badgers”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product Name	Price	Score	See Details	Buy Now
InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal	$136	8.7	Details	Buy
American Standard 10-US-AS-5 Garbage Disposer	$83	7.7	Details	Buy
MAX DISPOSER Garbage Disposal 1/2 HP	$99	7.5	Details	Buy
Waste Maid 10-US-WM-058-3B Garbage Disposal	$60	7.2	Details	Buy
GE Disposall Continuous Feed 1/3 Horsepower Garbage Disposer	$71	6.8	Details	Buy
Moen Prep Series PRO Garbage Disposal GXP50C	$85	6.6	Details	Buy
InSinkErator EVOLUTION 0.75HP Garbage Disposal	$249	6.5	Details	Buy
InSinkErator Power .75HP Garbage Disposal	$152	6.2	Details	Buy
InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal	$117	6.1	Details	Buy
Waste King 1/3 HP Garbage Disposal L-111	$77	6.1	Details	Buy
GE GFC525N Sink 1/2 HP Continuous Feed Disposer	$99	6.0	Details	Buy
InSinkErator Garbage Disposal Badger 1	$92	5.7	Details	Buy
KRAUS WasteGuard 3/4 HP Garbage Disposal	$163	5.6	Details	Buy
InSinkErator Power 1HP Garbage Disposal	$239	5.2	Details	Buy
InSinkErator EVOLUTION 1HP Garbage Disposal	$299	5.0	Details	Buy
InSinkErator Badger 1 Garbage Disposal	$93	4.6	Details	Buy
Whirlpool GC1000XE 1/3 hp in Sink Disposer	$89	3.8	Details	Buy
Moen Host Series 3/4 HP Continuous Feed Garbage Disposal	$136	3.6	Details	Buy
Frigidaire 1/2 HP Corded Garbage Disposal FF05DISPC1	$70	2.3	Details	Buy
InSinkErator Builder Series BLD50 Kitchen Garbage Disposal	$109	1.8	Details	Buy
Frigidaire 1/2 HP Direct Wire Garbage Disposal	$74	1.6	Details	Buy
InSinkErator PRO750 Pro Series Food Waste Disposal	$285	1.5	Details	Buy
TITAN Torque Garbage Disposal System	$69	0.7	Details	Buy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.

Variability in disposal power and user needs

“There’s different levels of disposal from like 0.25 hp up to maybe 5 hp.”➕

“The garbage disposal looks pretty rusty and is incredibly loud. I'm looking for something that'll last.”➕

Costco has exclusive models

“I think it’s the same 80022-ISE as seen on the insinkerator website with the only difference is the bottom isn’t stainless steel.”➕

“Yes. Same thing happens with TVs.”➕

“Insinkerator is the gold standard.”➕

Discussion on power differences between models

“More power, still quiet as the 500 but the inside is ALL stainless steel where the 500 is only galvanized (good stuff until the zinc coating wears off and then you’re screwed.)”➕

Common use of garbage disposals in US kitchens

“Many (maybe most) kitchens in the US have these built into the sink.”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.

Use of citrus peels for odor removal

“Just chucking a squeezed lemon / lime half in every once in a while after cocktail hour works for me.”➕

“Yes, I typically just do the ice cubes and really small lemon slices. It helps with any odors as well”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’

Concerns about plumbing compatibility with disposals

“This will be my first time changing out a disposal. I’m checking out options at Menards but curious which one is most recommended & what Horsepower is best.”➕

Concerns about garbage disposal pricing

“the prices are much more all over the place”➕

Compatibility concerns with existing plumbing

“Need a replacement for it and I am trying to figure out if it can be easily replaced by InSinkErator Power 900.”➕

“you just remove the old garbage disposal, you undo the screw and then give it a couple love taps from underneath and it pops out.”➕

Mix of cleaning methods for garbage disposals

“My sister dated a plumber, and his recommendation was similar, minus the bleach and baking soda.”➕

Exploring recommendations for garbage disposals

“Mine just exploded and poured about 10 gallons of water under my cabinets.”➕

Comparison of exclusive models and pricing

“these are the ones I am looking at”➕

Discussion on alternatives to InSinkErator

“We have a Moen that hasn't given us any issues. It's surprisingly quiet as well.”➕

“I bought a Waste King and have had zero issues — and I don’t go easy on it!!”➕

“Also have a Moen that we've had since October-ish of 2019 (right after we moved into our new place) and it's been great so far.”➕

Mention of Costco sales for disposals

“They frequently have disposals on sale. That's where I got my Moen.”➕

Discussion on compatibility of different InSinkErator models

“Mine is 14 years old at this point and I don't think I can get like for like.”➕

Clarification on hardwired vs. plug-in garbage disposals

“While replacing disposal you may want to have electrical wiring corrected.”➕

“There's two kinds of garbage disposals. Ones that plug into an outlet under the sink, and ones that are hard-wired.”➕

Concerns about DIY installation

“Trying to see if we can DIY.”➕

“Ooh, I like the size of that one.”➕

Consideration of alternative brands like Waste King

“Love it and comes with all the parts. Way cheaper and excellent quality compared to the badger/ insinkerator”➕

General advice on cleaning disposals

“All cheaper disposals will rust out. It really depends on how they're used.”➕

Discussions about disposal recommendations

“Suggestions for a good garbage disposal Any recommendations? The one we have currently isn't working too well.”➕

“Insinkerator it is! Appreciate all the responses!”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.

Childhood misconceptions about garbage disposals

“It wasn't until later I learned the food is more "whacked" into the side walls, until it explodes, and is washed away.”➕

“I thought that they were called "in sink erators" for the longest time until I said it once and nobody knew what I was talking about lol”➕

Commentary on the Moen product being relatively new with limited reviews

“Seems quieter? than the 1/2 insinkerator.”➕

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal

Curated from 75 real Reddit conversations

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal

Snoop's Take

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal

Small Under-Sink Spaces

Daily Meal Preparers

Noise-Sensitive Homes

Heavy-Duty Kitchens

What it does well!

Where it needs some work!

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Core Power Plays

Hidden Hero Hacks

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

Cautionary Callouts

You May Also Like

Explore more Garbage Disposals

Explore more Categories