InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal

Curated from 79 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: January 18, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6
Product Image 7
Product Image 8
Product Image 9
Product Image 10

InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal

Brand: InSinkErator
Price: $136
Snoop Score:
8.7
Sentiment
9.5
Popularity
10.0
Technical
8.0
Buy on Amazon for $136See All Garbage Disposals Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal is a powerful and compact continuous feed food waste disposer designed for effective kitchen waste management. Featuring a reliable 3/4 HP motor and easy installation, it caters to homeowners seeking a durable and efficient solution for everyday food scraps. Consumer feedback highlights several positive aspects, including its quiet operation and reliability. Users appreciate that "Insinkerator is the gold standard" for garbage disposals, with many noting the ease of installation and long-lasting performance compared to cheaper units. Additionally, many users find it easy to clean with citrus, further enhancing its appeal in maintaining a fresh kitchen environment. Overall, the InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal is highly recommended for its category, as it combines quality performance, ease of use, and trusted brand reputation, making it an excellent choice for homeowners looking to upgrade their kitchen waste disposal system.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Garbage Disposals

This thing is quiet, but be aware that the new baffle design will mean that more water will pool before draining.

Positive Feedback

Yep, you cannot put 5lbs of potato peels down the disposal, it just does not work.

Negative Feedback
Product
8.7
InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal
Buy on Amazon for $136
Small Under-Sink Spaces
4 / 10
Daily Meal Preparers
10 / 10
Noise-Sensitive Homes
10 / 10
Heavy-Duty Kitchens
8 / 10
See how this compares to all Garbage Disposals

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Quiet operation
“This thing is quiet, but be aware that the new baffle design will mean that more water will pool before draining.”➕
“For a few bucks more get the Badger 900 at HD. More power, still quiet as the 500 but the inside is ALL stainless steel where the 500 is only galvanized.”➕
“We love it and it is so so so quiet. Badgers are much louder compared to this.”➕
“Another vote for Insinkerator evolution. Stainless steel grinder for long life.”➕
Insinkerator is considered the gold standard
“Insinkerator is the gold standard.”➕
Reliable performance over time
“The cost savings on criterion vs insinkerator are basically nothing if you use the disposal over 5 years or more.”➕
Easy to clean with citrus
“Just chucking a squeezed lemon / lime half in every once in a while after cocktail hour works for me.”➕
“Yes, I typically just do the ice cubes and really small lemon slices.”➕
Manufacturer's recommendations are valued
“Ultimately, though, I like the recommendation to use the manufacturer's recommendations, but the above is what I follow personally.”➕
Easy installation
“Installation was a breeze and it runs flawlessly.”➕
“Functionality > Longevity > Sound”➕
“It’s super easy.”➕
“Follow the directions and it will be fine.”➕
Long-lasting performance compared to cheaper units
“This is all to say, cheap is cheap, insinkerator's cheap stuff won't last for a super long time, other companies cheap stuff may last just as long for a fraction.”➕
Easy installation with compatible brackets
“The bracket is part of the piece that gets inserted from above and that gets replaced real easily.”➕
Common bracket design minimizes installation time
“the hole in the sink is the same size for all of them, and the brackets take less than 5 minutes to swap, and the new disposal comes with a new (shiny!) bracket.”➕
Quiet and strong performance
“Quiet and strong only had it two years but the badger we took out was shite long before it quit working.”➕
Strong and effective performance
“Strong and quiet.”➕
InSinkErator is a trusted brand
“Insinkerator it is! Appreciate all the responses!”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Not suitable for large food scraps
“Yep, you cannot put 5lbs of potato peels down the disposal, it just does not work.”➕
Moen disposals do not perform comparably to Insinkerator
“Big mistake.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage DisposalInSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal$136
8.7
DetailsBuy
American Standard 10-US-AS-5 Garbage DisposerAmerican Standard 10-US-AS-5 Garbage Disposer$83
7.7
DetailsBuy
MAX DISPOSER Garbage Disposal 1/2 HPMAX DISPOSER Garbage Disposal 1/2 HP$99
7.5
DetailsBuy
Waste Maid 10-US-WM-058-3B Garbage DisposalWaste Maid 10-US-WM-058-3B Garbage Disposal$60
7.2
DetailsBuy
GE Disposall Continuous Feed 1/3 Horsepower Garbage DisposerGE Disposall Continuous Feed 1/3 Horsepower Garbage Disposer$71
6.8
DetailsBuy
Moen Prep Series PRO Garbage Disposal GXP50CMoen Prep Series PRO Garbage Disposal GXP50C$85
6.6
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator EVOLUTION 0.75HP Garbage DisposalInSinkErator EVOLUTION 0.75HP Garbage Disposal$249
6.5
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator Power .75HP Garbage DisposalInSinkErator Power .75HP Garbage Disposal$152
6.2
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage DisposalInSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal$117
6.1
DetailsBuy
Waste King 1/3 HP Garbage Disposal L-111Waste King 1/3 HP Garbage Disposal L-111$77
6.1
DetailsBuy
GE GFC525N Sink 1/2 HP Continuous Feed DisposerGE GFC525N Sink 1/2 HP Continuous Feed Disposer$99
6.0
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator Garbage Disposal Badger 1InSinkErator Garbage Disposal Badger 1$92
5.7
DetailsBuy
KRAUS WasteGuard 3/4 HP Garbage DisposalKRAUS WasteGuard 3/4 HP Garbage Disposal$163
5.6
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator Power 1HP Garbage DisposalInSinkErator Power 1HP Garbage Disposal$239
5.2
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator EVOLUTION 1HP Garbage DisposalInSinkErator EVOLUTION 1HP Garbage Disposal$299
5.0
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator Badger 1 Garbage DisposalInSinkErator Badger 1 Garbage Disposal$93
4.6
DetailsBuy
Whirlpool GC1000XE 1/3 hp in Sink DisposerWhirlpool GC1000XE 1/3 hp in Sink Disposer$89
3.8
DetailsBuy
Moen Host Series 3/4 HP Continuous Feed Garbage DisposalMoen Host Series 3/4 HP Continuous Feed Garbage Disposal$136
3.6
DetailsBuy
Frigidaire 1/2 HP Corded Garbage Disposal FF05DISPC1Frigidaire 1/2 HP Corded Garbage Disposal FF05DISPC1$70
2.3
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator Builder Series BLD50 Kitchen Garbage DisposalInSinkErator Builder Series BLD50 Kitchen Garbage Disposal$109
1.8
DetailsBuy
Frigidaire 1/2 HP Direct Wire Garbage DisposalFrigidaire 1/2 HP Direct Wire Garbage Disposal$74
1.6
DetailsBuy
InSinkErator PRO750 Pro Series Food Waste DisposalInSinkErator PRO750 Pro Series Food Waste Disposal$285
1.5
DetailsBuy
TITAN Torque Garbage Disposal SystemTITAN Torque Garbage Disposal System$69
0.7
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Moen and Waste King have similar internals
“It's surprisingly quiet as well.”➕
Common use of garbage disposals in US kitchens
“Many (maybe most) kitchens in the US have these built into the sink.”➕
Discussion about universal mounting brackets
“Different brand garbage disposal compatiblity? I'm trying to replace my broken Kitchen Aid garbage disposal with a Badger insinkerator.”➕
Perceptions of product loyalty and brand preference
“I never get recalls with Badgers.. I like to be a loyal customer so if the product works and I'm making money, why change?”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Discussion about DIY installation
“Trying to see if we can DIY.”➕
“Ooh, I like the size of that one.”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Costco often has exclusive models
“Yes. Same thing happens with TVs.”➕
Discussion on exclusive models at retailers
“these are the ones I am looking at”➕
Comparison of InSinkErator with cheaper brands
“I had an older badger prior that gave up the ghost.”➕
Costco frequently has sales on garbage disposals
“They frequently have disposals on sale. That's where I got my Moen.”➕
Discussion about compatibility of different InSinkErator models.
“Mine is 14 years old at this point and I don't think I can get like for like.”➕
Cleaning tips for garbage disposals
“All cheaper disposals will rust out. It really depends on how they're used.”➕
Discussion on warranties and assembly locations
“Moen Garbage Disposal - Thoughts? Don’t install them often, I like the moen size and price point.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Perceptions of garbage disposal effectiveness vary
“The ones in my house and my parents’ house have been going strong since the 1980s.”➕
“Modern appliances are designed to be disposable (no pun intended).”➕
“Same and my mom throws everything down there.”➕
“There’s different levels of disposal from like 0.25 hp up to maybe 5 hp. Each one is rated for different types of use so my rule of thumb is get the one one step above your intended use and you’ll probably be fine.”➕
Perceptions of garbage disposal longevity vary
“Less than three years later it's failed.”➕
“They are easy to swap and not that expensive, I would just assume you’ll need a new one every 5-10 years.”➕
Garbage disposals are not repairable when leaking from the bottom.
“They're fairly cheap and if you're handy, you can replace it yourself.”➕
“mine had same bottom leak issue and plumber replaced as it was unrepairable”➕
Important to ensure electrical wiring is properly secured when replacing garbage disposals.
“While replacing disposal you may want to have electrical wiring corrected.”➕
“There's two kinds of garbage disposals. Ones that plug into an outlet under the sink, and ones that are hard-wired.”➕
Recommendations against using food disposals
“Badger 500 sink food disposal is only 5 years old and is rusted beyond repair.”➕
Mixed experiences with garbage disposals
“Buy a Badger 5 from Insinkerator. Then read up on what to put in it, and what NOT to put in it.”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more Garbage Disposals
GE GFC525N Sink 1/2 HP Continuous Feed Disposer
GE GFC525N Sink 1/2 HP Continuous Feed Disposer
Explore
InSinkErator EVOLUTION 0.75HP Garbage Disposal
InSinkErator EVOLUTION 0.75HP Garbage Disposal
Explore
Frigidaire 1/2 HP Corded Garbage Disposal FF05DISPC1
Frigidaire 1/2 HP Corded Garbage Disposal FF05DISPC1
Explore
Explore more Categories
Top Electric Herb & Spice Grinders
Top Electric Herb & Spice Grinders
Explore
Top Vacuum Sealer Bags for Long-Lasting Food Storage
Top Vacuum Sealer Bags for Long-Lasting Food Storage
Explore
Top Countertop Microwave Ovens for Quick, Convenient Cooking
Top Countertop Microwave Ovens for Quick, Convenient Cooking
Explore