SEO Link List

appliances

Dishwashers

Small Kitchen Appliances

automotive & industrial

Accent & Off Road Lighting

Accessories

Accessories & Parts

Body & Trim

Brake Tools

Bulbs

Bumper Stickers, Decals & Magnets

Bumpers & Bumper Accessories

Car Electronics

Cleaning & Maintenance

Diagnostic, Test & Measurement Tools

Drive Train

Electrical Appliances

Engine Cooling

Engine Tools

Exhaust & Emissions

Exterior

Exterior Care

Finishing

Gaskets

Glass Care

Hood Scoops & Vents

Horns & Accessories

Ignition & Electrical

Interior

Interior Care

Jump Starters, Battery Chargers & Portable Power

Lighting & Electrical

Mirrors & Parts

Plumbing

Pullers

Running Boards & Steps

Safety

Shocks, Struts & Suspension

Snow & Ice

Steering & Suspension Tools

Thread Repair Kits

Tires

Tools & Equipment

Towing Products & Winches

Trailer Accessories

Truck Bed & Tailgate Accessories

baby products

Activity & Entertainment

Apparel & Accessories

Baby & Toddler Toys

Baby Care

Car Seats & Accessories

Diapering

Feeding

Gifts

Nursery

Potty Training

Safety

Strollers & Accessories

Travel Gear

beauty & personal care

Foot, Hand & Nail Care

Hair Care

Makeup

Personal Care

electronics

Camera & Photo

Car & Vehicle Electronics

Cell Phones & Accessories

Computers & Accessories

Home Audio

Household Batteries, Chargers & Accessories

Television & Video

Video Game Consoles & Accessories

Wearable Technology

health & household

Baby & Child Care

Health Care

House Supplies

Oral Care

Personal Care

Sexual Wellness

Sports Nutrition

Wellness & Relaxation

home & kitchen

Bath

Bedding

Heating, Cooling & Air Quality

Kitchen & Dining

Lighting & Ceiling Fans

Seasonal Decor

Storage & Organization

Vacuums & Floor Care

office products

Educational Supplies

Office & School Supplies

patio, lawn & garden

Gardening & Lawn Care

Outdoor Decor

Outdoor Heating & Cooling

Outdoor Lighting

Outdoor Power Tools

Patio Furniture & Accessories

Pest Control

pet supplies

Birds

Cats

Dogs

Fish & Aquatic Pets

Horses

Reptiles & Amphibians

sports & outdoors

Exercise & Fitness

Hunting & Fishing

Outdoor Recreation

Sports

toys & games

Arts & Crafts

Collectible Toys

Dolls & Accessories

Dress Up & Pretend Play

Games & Accessories

Kids' Electronics

Puppets & Puppet Theaters

Puzzles

Remote & App Controlled Vehicles & Parts

Sports & Outdoor Play

Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys

Tricycles, Scooters & Wagons

Vehicles

video games

PC

PlayStation 4

PlayStation 5

Xbox One

Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker

Curated from 90 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: April 27, 2025

Product Image 1
Product Image 2
Product Image 3
Product Image 4
Product Image 5
Product Image 6

Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker

Brand: Nostalgia
Price: $49
Snoop Score:
3.4
Sentiment
5.0
Popularity
0.6
Technical
3.2
Buy on Amazon for $49See All Reviews
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

The Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker is a vintage-style appliance designed to create homemade soft serve ice cream, frozen yogurt, or gelato in just 20 minutes. With its user-friendly design and the ability to make unique flavor combinations, it offers a delightful ice cream experience for families and hobbyists alike. Consumer feedback has highlighted the Nostalgia ice cream maker as a great entry-level machine for those new to ice cream making, with one user stating, "I have this model for the price, it is a great entry to ice cream making." However, some users have encountered challenges, particularly with calibration issues and the positioning of ice cream sticks, leading to inconsistent results. Many reported that the machine's stick inserter is not timed correctly, impacting the quality of the ice cream produced. Overall, while the Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker has its drawbacks, it is still recommended for anyone looking for an enjoyable and fun way to make ice cream at home, particularly for beginners who are willing to experiment and troubleshoot as needed.

Not for you? Check out our other rated

I have this model for the price, it is a great entry to ice cream making.

Positive Feedback

Ice cream machine that never puts sticks right

Negative Feedback
Product
3.4
Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker
Buy on Amazon for $49
Quick Single Batches
9 / 10
Continuous Batch Production
3 / 10
Customized Dietary Needs
5 / 10
Family Gatherings & Parties
3 / 10
See how this compares to all Reviews

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.
Great entry-level ice cream maker
“I have this model for the price, it is a great entry to ice cream making.”➕
“I put my empty ice cream maker bowl in the freezer last night in preparation for finally breaking it in.”➕
“Most the time I can get it to make ice cream, but it's usually still softer than I'd like, and at least one time it didn't really work at all.”➕
User-friendly for hobbyists
“My old ice and salt machine has never had a problem with anything I've tried to add into the ice cream.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.
Ice cream sticks are not positioned correctly
“Ice cream machine that never puts sticks right”➕
“It‘s even the same side, it‘s left, right, left, right…”➕
“Yup, the treats are coming down in pairs. Sticky is consistent.”➕
“It actually looks like the ice creams aren't lined up consistently”➕
Calibration issues with the machine
“It’s probably not calibrated correctly”➕
“The stick inserter doesn’t appear “smart”, so that means the issue Is upstream. It is definitely a timing or calibration issue with the machine that creates or places the ice cream on the trays.”➕
“Too far apart. Or the machine hasn't been calibrated correctly”➕
“Its not the creams fault, the shooter is just not timed correctly.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product NameImagePriceScoreCompareSee DetailsBuy Now
Whynter Ice Cream Maker Machine Automatic 2.1 QtWhynter Ice Cream Maker Machine Automatic 2.1 Qt$286
7.6
DetailsBuy
Hamilton Beach Electric Ice Cream MakerHamilton Beach Electric Ice Cream Maker$54
6.5
DetailsBuy
Cuisinart ICE-21RP1 Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream MakerCuisinart ICE-21RP1 Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream Maker$58
6.5
DetailsBuy
Ninja NC501 CREAMi Deluxe Ice Cream MakerNinja NC501 CREAMi Deluxe Ice Cream Maker$199
6.4
DetailsBuy
Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream MakerNinja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker$199
6.3
DetailsBuy
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker, ICE30BCP1Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker, ICE30BCP1$78
6.2
DetailsBuy
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, 1.5 QuartCuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, 1.5 Quart$50
6.1
DetailsBuy
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, ICE-70P1Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, ICE-70P1$144
6.1
DetailsBuy
Ninja CREAMi Ice Cream MakerNinja CREAMi Ice Cream Maker$199
6.0
DetailsBuy
VEVOR Commercial Ice Cream MakerVEVOR Commercial Ice Cream Maker$1276
6.0
DetailsBuy
Cuisinart ICE-21PKP1 Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream MakerCuisinart ICE-21PKP1 Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream Maker$50
5.7
DetailsBuy
Elite Gourmet Americana Collection Elite EIM520M Ice Cream MakerElite Gourmet Americana Collection Elite EIM520M Ice Cream Maker$24
5.6
DetailsBuy
VEVOR Commercial Ice Cream MachineVEVOR Commercial Ice Cream Machine$1115
5.6
DetailsBuy
Lello 4080 Musso Lussino Ice Cream MakerLello 4080 Musso Lussino Ice Cream Maker$699
5.5
DetailsBuy
DASH My Pint Ice Cream Maker MachineDASH My Pint Ice Cream Maker Machine$21
5.2
DetailsBuy
Elite Gourmet Maxi-Matic EIM-520 Automatic Ice Cream MakerElite Gourmet Maxi-Matic EIM-520 Automatic Ice Cream Maker$24
4.2
DetailsBuy
DASH My Mug Ice Cream MakerDASH My Mug Ice Cream Maker$34
4.0
DetailsBuy
Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream MakerNostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker$49
3.4
DetailsBuy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.
Discussion on the mechanics of the machine
“Its likely there are two extruders further up the line and they got placed too close together after maintenance.”➕
“Probably set for the spacing between two boxes when it's between two Popsicles in the same box.”➕
“I reckon it’s more like the ice creams are not placed right by the previous stage.”➕
“In engineering, this kind of problem can be incredibly frustrating.”➕
Discussion on the mechanics of freezing
“This is basically a heat transfer problem. You want the bowl as cold as you can get, since that’s the only thing freezing your mix.”➕
“Everything should be as cold as possible, your bowl might be ready if your mix is cold.”➕
“Obviously this is a thermo dynamics question. And obviously you need to keep the freezer bowl in the freezer until it’s frozen solid.”➕
Unexpected twist on nostalgia with ice cream truck
“What a waste of money.”➕
“That ice cream truck is definitely not the nostalgia trip you expected! 👀😱”➕
Discussion about childhood ice cream-making experiences
“The mysterious origin of upside down Big Wheels and Ice Cream.”➕
“I know that older ice cream makers were hand cranked.”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.
Humorous remarks about ice cream placement
“They are called ice creams , hope this helps”➕
“Not iced yet 😉”➕
Tips and techniques shared for making caramel
“Once it hits the target temp, dump cream in it and stir until mixed.”➕
“Is that sorta like butterscotch?”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’
Discussion on ice cream makers in general
“Best home ice cream maker? Hey guys! I'm looking at all the ice cream makers and feeling overwhelmed with choices...what is the best machine for a newbie with kids? Thaaaanks!”➕
“I was gifted a Cuisinart ICE-21 as my first ice cream maker. It's been great and suited most of my needs.”➕
“Agreeing with the others that the Cuisinart ICE-21 (or even ICE-20) is a great place to start.”➕
Humorous anecdotes about cooking mishaps
“enameled cast iron Dutch ovens that I’ve sacrificed to the cause.”➕
“I do sugar, cream, butter, salt all at once and cook to the temperature I need.”➕
“It’ll be quicker if you use granulated white sugar with the small crystals.”➕
“Big crystals”➕
Discussion on churning times and techniques
“Makes for a shorter churn.”➕
“You will always struggle with a freezer bowl.”➕
Comparisons with other ice cream makers
“I've been using it for the last two years and made ice cream through summer where it does get warmer.”➕
“I was very impressed with the nostalgia maker at first use, after churning the ice cream was actually harder than what I typically get from the cuisinart bowls.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.
Discussion on ice cream making methods
“Has anyone used the machines that use ice and salt? The more popular ones are the Nostalgia brand.”➕
“I will save my money then. The machines that are usually recommended here are over my budget and the ice and salt machines are so cheap but it seems that in the long run I would be wasting my money.”➕
“It's worth checking your local thrift stores to see if they have any. I've seen a couple Cuisinarts at Goodwill for just a few bucks.”➕
“Having never used the newer ice cream makers you're talking about, I can only say good things about the traditional method.”➕
Discussion on challenges of making caramel
“Yes making caramel is hard but it shouldn’t be that hard.”➕
“This is very practical guidance.”➕
“Honestly a good and funny review”➕
“I make the burnt sugar.”➕
Concerns about ice cream consistency related to batch size
“I don’t think the temperature will be an issue if you have enough salt and ice.”➕

You May Also Like

Explore more
Cuisinart ICE-21RP1 Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream Maker
Cuisinart ICE-21RP1 Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream Maker
Explore
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, ICE-70P1
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, ICE-70P1
Explore
VEVOR Commercial Ice Cream Maker
VEVOR Commercial Ice Cream Maker
Explore
Explore more Categories
Top Electric Coffee Percolators for Rich, Full-Bodied Brews
Top Electric Coffee Percolators for Rich, Full-Bodied Brews
Explore
Top Mini Cupcake Makers
Top Mini Cupcake Makers
Explore
Top Electric Skillets for Easy, Versatile Cooking
Top Electric Skillets for Easy, Versatile Cooking
Explore